Notre Dame Jersey Discussion Thread

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • beavisrules
    Senior Member
    • Sep 2006
    • 159

    Notre Dame Jersey Discussion Thread

    Like many of you, I have learned so much from GUU over the years about game used jerseys. However, I haven't felt like I have contributed much back to the community. Well, I hope to rectify that with a Notre Dame jersey thread. I am by no means an "expert", but I have learned quite a bit over the years from research and interacting with numerous collectors. So I thought I would try to intermittently post information about Notre Dame jerseys to help out those interested in learning more.

    For the first post, I am going to address one of the most repetitive errors I have seen with ND jerseys, which occurs on ebay about once every 3 to 4 months (at least). And that is the auction for a "Game Worn #3 Notre Dame jersey" made by champion. If you have ever watched for game worn Notre Dame jerseys, you no doubt have seen the following item for sale:




    On first look, it may appear to be a legit 1994 Gamer worn by Ron Powlus. But it is not. The majority of the specs for this jersey are correct: solid cuffed sleeves, screened numbers (sewn numbers did NOT appear on game worn ND jerseys in the 1990s), dome on the neck line, spandex sides, and year sewn in the tagging (which did occur for 1994 jerseys, if the tags were not removed from jersey modification by the equipment manager). However, this is actually an authentic jersey that was sold to the public - interestingly, the retail authentics sold at stores did NOT include the 1994 year sewn in the tags; I suspect the jerseys sold directly by the school did include the year stitched, but I have never been able to formally confirm this. Anyway, here's the quick and easy reason that you can tell this is not a gamer - the front #3 is wrong. Powlus wore a jersey with a much wider #3, as opposed to the authentic jerseys that feature the skinny #3. Here's an example of the the wide #3:

    So, the next time a "game worn #3 Notre Dame jersey" pops up on ebay, check out the width of the front #3 - chances are, it is an authentic.
    -Mike

    Always looking for Notre Dame memorabilia
    Private messages ARE enabled
  • sox83cubs84
    Banned
    • Apr 2009
    • 8902

    #2
    Re: Notre Dame Jersey Discussion Thread

    Worth mentioning, for sure...sometimes these Powlus non-gamers seem almost as common as the 1989-90 ScoreBoard jerseys that confuse some baseball collectors. Thanks for the education.

    Dave M.
    Chicago area

    Comment

    • beavisrules
      Senior Member
      • Sep 2006
      • 159

      #3
      Other Champion Authentic Blue ND Jerseys from 1994 to 1997

      One more thing to note about the "Authentic" Champion Notre Dame home blue jerseys from the 1994-1997 era - the #3 was not the only number made into an authentic jersey that is very similar to a gamer - the #1 jersey was also made available for public purchase given Derrick Mayes popularity at the time. I have seen a few of these Mayes authentics listed as gamers on ebay, but none have been game worn - they were actually authentics. Also note that many of them had a Mayes signature on the front number 1 - again, not a gamer, but a retail authentic - they were sold by a now-defunct company right after Mayes graduated from ND. Here's an example of an authentic non-gamer #1 jersey:


      One last note before I leave the 1994 - 1997 era home blue authentics - I was asked once about the #44 jersey (worn by Marc Edwards at the time), and whether this was also a jersey made into a retail authentic. This is not clear to me - I have seen only 2 of these authentic #44 home (blue) jerseys ever listed for sale. I have never seen them available for retail purchase in any of the old catalogs or sale listings I have access to. It is possible that the athletic department had a few extras of the #44 jersey made up to give to VIPs (aka significant donors). But, alas, the #44 jersey history from this era is not completely clear to me - perhaps they truly were gamers (or at least team issued) after all, because I have been unable to prove otherwise thus far.
      -Mike

      Always looking for Notre Dame memorabilia
      Private messages ARE enabled

      Comment

      • beavisrules
        Senior Member
        • Sep 2006
        • 159

        #4
        The "Authentic" Green Champion Jersey from 1995

        The only other jersey made into a retail authentic from the 1994 - 1997 era was, yet again, the #3 jersey - but this time it was the green version of the jersey. Interestingly, champion and/or Notre Dame opted to use the correct, widened-style #3 on this retail sold jersey, which has prompted numerous people to again list this as "game worn" on ebay in the past. Sorry, not game worn. How can I be so sure? From 1994 to 1997, the green jersey was used only once, and this was in the 1995 Fiesta Bowl. The green jersey was not used again until 1999, and the style had changed by then (which we'll touch on in a subsequent post). And I bet Powlus still has his gamer from the bowl. But, any green jersey (as shown below) without the bowl game patch is a retail authentic, no questions asked. Also, the retail authentic green #3 jersey was used by upper deck for a signature jersey by Montana and Holtz - you'll see these hologramed jerseys pop up on ebay once in a while.

        Here's an example of the retail authentic:

        Here's what the actual gamers look like (note the bowl patch obviously):
        -Mike

        Always looking for Notre Dame memorabilia
        Private messages ARE enabled

        Comment

        • dcgreg25
          Senior Member
          • Jan 2008
          • 1416

          #5
          Re: Notre Dame Jersey Discussion Thread

          Cool thread Mike, this is helpful information for a lot of people. Thanks!

          Comment

          • genius
            Senior Member
            • Aug 2007
            • 539

            #6
            Re: Notre Dame Jersey Discussion Thread

            Awesome Theismann jersey on AMI right now. Nice video shot from that Cotton Bowl clearly shows the NOB, www.youtube.com/watch?v=xPJHw4ubVk8

            Comment

            • sox83cubs84
              Banned
              • Apr 2009
              • 8902

              #7
              Re: Notre Dame Jersey Discussion Thread

              This Notre Dame thread is marvelous...keep adding to it! I knew of the blue #3s, but most of the rest was news to me...always willing to learn more.

              Dave M.
              Chicago area

              Comment

              • genius
                Senior Member
                • Aug 2007
                • 539

                #8
                Re: Notre Dame Jersey Discussion Thread

                Highest bid for the Theismann was $11K with reserve NOT met!

                Comment

                • beavisrules
                  Senior Member
                  • Sep 2006
                  • 159

                  #9
                  Re: Notre Dame Jersey Discussion Thread

                  genius, that Theismann jersey is outstanding. To be honest, I was hoping the University itself would bid and win it so it could be displayed on campus for all the enjoy. What do you bet the reserve is set at? I suspect it is at 25k.

                  Also, did you look closely at the pic of the two jerseys? I was struck by the significant difference in the sleeve length relative to the #7 on both jerseys; seems odd to me to have such a difference. Warm weather versus cold weather? Jerseys from different years? Thoughts?
                  -Mike

                  Always looking for Notre Dame memorabilia
                  Private messages ARE enabled

                  Comment

                  • genius
                    Senior Member
                    • Aug 2007
                    • 539

                    #10
                    Re: Notre Dame Jersey Discussion Thread

                    I wonder if they even knew about it? That would be where it belongs. Reserve could have been $50K, not sure why Theismann would part with those other than major-cash. I have one of the same set of navy short-sleeve versions, couldn't believe how flimsy it was when I received. Cotton Bowl shirt just might have been designed for more of a winter's day. Maybe he'll donate it to the alma-mater, I would rather have a slice of immortality at ND than sell for a measly $25K (if I'm Theismann, of course!).

                    Comment

                    • kudu
                      Senior Member
                      • May 2007
                      • 775

                      #11
                      Re: Notre Dame Jersey Discussion Thread

                      Does anyone know what year(s) Rawlings made jerseys for the Notre Dame baseball team?

                      Click image for larger version

Name:	irish1.JPG
Views:	1
Size:	151.4 KB
ID:	680207

                      Click image for larger version

Name:	irish2.JPG
Views:	1
Size:	133.9 KB
ID:	680208

                      Comment

                      • kudu
                        Senior Member
                        • May 2007
                        • 775

                        #12
                        Re: Notre Dame Jersey Discussion Thread

                        Nevermind, found my answer in this thread:

                        Comment

                        • MichaelofSF
                          Senior Member
                          • Apr 2007
                          • 503

                          #13
                          Re: Other Champion Authentic Blue ND Jerseys from 1994 to 1997

                          Originally posted by beavisrules
                          One more thing to note about the "Authentic" Champion Notre Dame home blue jerseys from the 1994-1997 era - the #3 was not the only number made into an authentic jersey that is very similar to a gamer - the #1 jersey was also made available for public purchase given Derrick Mayes popularity at the time. I have seen a few of these Mayes authentics listed as gamers on ebay, but none have been game worn - they were actually authentics. Also note that many of them had a Mayes signature on the front number 1 - again, not a gamer, but a retail authentic - they were sold by a now-defunct company right after Mayes graduated from ND. Here's an example of an authentic non-gamer #1 jersey:


                          One last note before I leave the 1994 - 1997 era home blue authentics - I was asked once about the #44 jersey (worn by Marc Edwards at the time), and whether this was also a jersey made into a retail authentic. This is not clear to me - I have seen only 2 of these authentic #44 home (blue) jerseys ever listed for sale. I have never seen them available for retail purchase in any of the old catalogs or sale listings I have access to. It is possible that the athletic department had a few extras of the #44 jersey made up to give to VIPs (aka significant donors). But, alas, the #44 jersey history from this era is not completely clear to me - perhaps they truly were gamers (or at least team issued) after all, because I have been unable to prove otherwise thus far.
                          http://sports.mearsonlineauctions.co...RS-Auction-LOA)-

                          Is this one of those jerseys?

                          Comment

                          • beavisrules
                            Senior Member
                            • Sep 2006
                            • 159

                            #14
                            Re: Notre Dame Jersey Discussion Thread

                            Michael,

                            Yes it is. A company called Killir Sports released a catalog of Notre Dame memorabilia in fall 1996 (you can still obtain one of these catalogs from old 1996 Notre Dame football programs, as they were inserts). On page 20 of this catalog (as I have one for reference), they sold a "Derrick Mayes autographed Authentic ND Navy #1 jersey" for $99.95 - the autograph was in black sharpie on the front #1.

                            Other reasons this is not a Mayes gamer - it can't be a 1993, because it is the wrong tagging (the dome appeared starting in 1994). It isn't a 1994, because all 1994s had the year sewn into the tag. It isn't a 95 or 96, because Mayes wouldn't have had a gamer without significant wear - the tags on this jersey are way too crisp on the corners for this to be a gamer for starters, and Mayes blocked a lot in Holtz's offense, meaning shoulder impact marks are a must for a true Mayes gamer in his junior and senior years. There are a few other reasons that this is not a Mayes gamer that I will not disclose here, mainly to prevent anyone from "adjusting" a retail authentic in the future. I have never seen a true Mayes gamer from ND in the past 10 years for sale - I have seen at least 10 jerseys claiming to be Mayes gamers during this time, but all were missing the telltale characteristics needed, and were simply retail authentics.

                            Hope this helps.
                            -Mike

                            Always looking for Notre Dame memorabilia
                            Private messages ARE enabled

                            Comment

                            • beavisrules
                              Senior Member
                              • Sep 2006
                              • 159

                              #15
                              Re: Notre Dame Jersey Discussion Thread

                              Here's the actual page of the catalog scanned for your review. Certainly, everyone is entitled to their own opinion on the jersey up for auction on MEARS site - I am simply putting in my own opinion based on my years of experience and research on ND jerseys, as well as for the education value regarding ND jerseys in this thread. The good news? It is definitely an authentic game-style jersey, and I would be comfortable with the autograph as well even if it doesn't have an original Killir sports LOA with it.
                              -Mike

                              Always looking for Notre Dame memorabilia
                              Private messages ARE enabled

                              Comment

                              Working...