Bat Authentication

[cjmedina1]

I have some bats that I want to send in but not sure who to go with .PSA or Mears.Please post or email me Thanks for you time

carliemedina3@sbcglobal.net

Carlie Medina III

[dluengo21]

Re: Bat Authentication

I have not had anything authenticated by MEARS, but I continue to read many posts from collectors who have found discrepancies on their items.It seems to me that your best bet would be to go with PSA, as I have not seen any negative feedback on their authentications on the forums and Vince Malta is regarded as one of the best. Just my opinion, but MEARS seems to be on every item lately and there seems to be quite a few errors that have been reported on this site that should not be. Maybe they have gotten too big too fast and are being overworked and items are slipping thru the cracks.

[cjmedina1]

Re: Bat Authentication

Thank you for the reply.I have read many post about Mears.Some good and Bad.I have no question about my bats.It just seems if you have a coa from a big time company you can get more money for your stuff.I have 2 bats of Mark Mcgwire.One is a 1986 sign gamer.This bat has tons a pine tar and has the correct markings for a 1986 bat.My other bat is a 2000 sign gamer.This bat has the most pine tar and game use from any Mcgwire bats that I have seen.If some one can help me on how to post some pics I can do that

[ChrisCavalier]

Re: Bat Authentication

Hello Carlie-

There are some instructions on how to post images in the FAQ section of the forums. Here is the link:

http://www.gameuseduniverse.com/vb_forum/faq.php?faq=vb_read_and_post#faq_post_images

In addition, if you would like more information, the FAQ section can hopefully provide more perspective. Alternatively, you can always post any additional questions you may have on the forum and there are people who will be glad to help whenever possible.

Sincerely,
Christopher Cavalier

[Rboitano]

Re: Bat Authentication

Id like to see some pics of those Mcgwire gamers, they sound great.

[ghostkid]

Re: Bat Authentication

Carlie,

I feel that both PSA/DNA and MEARS are good choices for authenticating your game used bats. Some bats in my collection have been authenticated by the PSA/DNA folks, while others have been authenticated by MEARS. For the vintage stuff, It seems to me that PSA/DNA primarily specializes in Louisville Slugger bats, while the MEARS team is spending a great deal of time ucovering new information about pro model bats of the non-traditional variety (Hanna, Zinn Beck, etc). In summary, I believe either would be a good choice for your bats.

[dluengo21]

Re: Bat Authentication

Vince Malta is regarded as one of the best.

Thanks Chris for making the change for me. I accidently put Jimmy Spence when I meant to put in Vince Malta as I know that Spence only does autographs. It was late last night and I'm getting old and forgetful.As this was my first post I am just getting used to the format. I just got home from work and I do not have internet access from my job. I now know that I have the ability to make corrrections to my posts. That is an easy feature to use. Thanks again.

[beni0016]

Re: Bat Authentication

Both MEARS and PSA are great in my opinion. I personally have a tremendous amount of ferspect for Dave Bushing and faith in his expertise when it comes to bats. I have not dealt with Dave alot but the times I have have been great experiences and I have been impressed with his insight.

However, for my money John Taube is the best out there. He has helped me personally with many bats that I have questions about and has always been willing to provide a thoughful second opinion as well as info regarding H&B records. Again, when it comes to bats I don't think that you can go wrong with either so you may want to check prices but I can tell you from personal experience that John Taube (PSA) is one of the best guys in the hobby.

Regards,
Andy

[cjmedina1]

Re: Bat Authentication

86 Mac bat full size shot

[cjmedina1]

Re: Bat Authentication

Mcgwire 1986 bat knob with pine tar

[cjmedina1]

Re: Bat Authentication

Autograph detail.I belive this is a vintage autograph.There is a 1986 minoe league jersey that autograph and a team letter.They look almost the same.I would only guess that this could have been a minor league bat.Not sure if any experts can comment

[cjmedina1]

Re: Bat Authentication

Back of the bat.As you can see there is a piece is missing.Not sure why.There is blue marks as you can see

[cjmedina1]

Re: Bat Authentication

Side view

[cjmedina1]

Re: Bat Authentication

This is the top end of the bat.It has Mac as you can see.

[cjmedina1]

Re: Bat Authentication

And know the bat knob.It has the correct marks 265b 351 6.And also has Mac written on the bottom.