Seeking opinions from the peanut gallery

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Masimen
    Senior Member
    • Jun 2008
    • 424

    Seeking opinions from the peanut gallery

    Ok folks, gonna keep this as brief as I can. Please bare with me. I purchased a game used Jorge Posada glove and received it yesterday. This glove was once part of a GUU auction and it supposedly originated from a Posada charity auction. As you can see it is inscribed Game Used 07. Before I purchased the glove I knew it wasn't one of his main gamers in 07 as he had switched to the lighter woven back and this glove was all leather, but the use looked great and the glove was looked legit to me. I just assumed it was a carryover or a practice glove. In any case, the glove arrived and I started searching getty last night. Found nothing in 07 that matched and then just started going backwards year by year. Much to my surprise and delight I believe I have photomatched the glove to the 2nd half of the 01 season all the way through game 3 of the world series. of course I can't match it to each and every game, but I believe this was the glove that he was wearing when Jeter made the famous "flip play" to Posada.

    Below are the 2 best pics I could find to match it. The pic of Posada by himself is from Game 5 of the LCS and the pic of him and Pettite is from Game 2 of the LDS

    So, I am looking for everyone's thoughts on the match. I think it is a pretty clear match, but I have looked at way too many pictures of catchers mitts the last 24 hours. I would also love to hear any and all opinions on the the inscription. My best guess looking at the glove and seeing that the inscription was added at later time than the signature or at least with a different pen is that he may have signed the glove and had it laying around or in storage and then when he needed one to give to an auction he or one of his people got the glove and had him erroneously inscribe it 07. I suppose he could have used it for practice in 07 after the fact, but that seems like an awful long time to be using that same glove.

    Aside from the circled areas, if you notice the seam that runs along the index finger you can see how it turns in and then back out as it gets to the end of the finger. That seems to match perfectly as well. What do you guys think?
    Attached Files
  • sctizzle
    Senior Member
    • Nov 2005
    • 419

    #2
    Re: Seeking opinions from the peanut gallery

    Steve,

    That is incredible!! Looks like a perfect match to me.

    Very jealous of the pickup!! Congrats!!!!

    Scott

    Comment

    • CampWest
      Senior Member
      • May 2008
      • 1507

      #3
      Re: Seeking opinions from the peanut gallery

      Have you checked the date/dot code? Are there any dots under a Rawlings branding or a 4 letter code like EBEH?
      sigpic
      Wes Campbell

      Comment

      • Masimen
        Senior Member
        • Jun 2008
        • 424

        #4
        Re: Seeking opinions from the peanut gallery

        Originally posted by CampWest
        Have you checked the date/dot code? Are there any dots under a Rawlings branding or a 4 letter code like EBEH?
        Hey Wes,
        Yes I have checked and I can't find a date code anywhere on the glove, no dot or letter code.

        Comment

        • CampWest
          Senior Member
          • May 2008
          • 1507

          #5
          Re: Seeking opinions from the peanut gallery

          Originally posted by Masimen
          Hey Wes,
          Yes I have checked and I can't find a date code anywhere on the glove, no dot or letter code.
          Huh... I would think it should be one or the other somewhere...

          take a look at this thread... There are some pics that may help you see what to look for... if you can find a code, you should be able to come up with the date.



          I think if it was used in 2001... it would likely have been made in 2000 (5 dots) or 2001 (1 dot). If 2007, it would have the BLACKHORSE code and be something like EBEH/CBCK...
          sigpic
          Wes Campbell

          Comment

          • Masimen
            Senior Member
            • Jun 2008
            • 424

            #6
            Re: Seeking opinions from the peanut gallery

            Originally posted by CampWest
            Huh... I would think it should be one or the other somewhere...

            take a look at this thread... There are some pics that may help you see what to look for... if you can find a code, you should be able to come up with the date.



            I think if it was used in 2001... it would likely have been made in 2000 (5 dots) or 2001 (1 dot). If 2007, it would have the BLACKHORSE code and be something like EBEH/CBCK...
            Yea, it is strange. I looked everywhere. A few times. After doing the research I would have expected a dot code, but nothing. I have the same issue with a Paul Oneill glove that i have from the same era. No sign of any date stamp anywhere.

            Comment

            • jsr418
              Senior Member
              • Apr 2010
              • 119

              #7
              Re: Seeking opinions from the peanut gallery

              From the photos, it looks good to me. What an incredible pick up. Congratulations!

              Comment

              • legaleagle92481
                Banned
                • Oct 2009
                • 2538

                #8
                Re: Seeking opinions from the peanut gallery

                The inscription is ok alot of people's 1s look like 7s. It was probably added later on. Happens alot.

                Comment

                • CampWest
                  Senior Member
                  • May 2008
                  • 1507

                  #9
                  Re: Seeking opinions from the peanut gallery

                  Originally posted by legaleagle92481
                  alot of people's 1s look like 7s.
                  Thats why my wedding cake never showed up! Wedding was on Sunday Sept 1 - Labor Day weekend. Cake lady thought it was the following Saturday Sept 7. My mother in law wrote on the check memo, "for 9/1 wedding" or something and even though we told the cake lady several times it was labor day weekend and Sunday the 1st and she said no problem. Nonetheless, when she booked it into her calendar she confused the 1 for a 7 and went to the lake Labor Day weekend.
                  sigpic
                  Wes Campbell

                  Comment

                  • Masimen
                    Senior Member
                    • Jun 2008
                    • 424

                    #10
                    Re: Seeking opinions from the peanut gallery

                    Originally posted by CampWest
                    Thats why my wedding cake never showed up! Wedding was on Sunday Sept 1 - Labor Day weekend. Cake lady thought it was the following Saturday Sept 7. My mother in law wrote on the check memo, "for 9/1 wedding" or something and even though we told the cake lady several times it was labor day weekend and Sunday the 1st and she said no problem. Nonetheless, when she booked it into her calendar she confused the 1 for a 7 and went to the lake Labor Day weekend.
                    Are you insinuating that your mother-in-law inscribed my glove?

                    Comment

                    • CampWest
                      Senior Member
                      • May 2008
                      • 1507

                      #11
                      Re: Seeking opinions from the peanut gallery

                      Originally posted by Masimen
                      Are you insinuating that your mother-in-law inscribed my glove?
                      Precisely, Yes. Jorge Posada is my mother in law...
                      sigpic
                      Wes Campbell

                      Comment

                      • vdsporty25
                        Senior Member
                        • Feb 2009
                        • 405

                        #12
                        Re: Seeking opinions from the peanut gallery

                        That is a sick item!! Nice match as well....looks great to me!
                        Thanks a lot
                        Josh

                        Comment

                        • Masimen
                          Senior Member
                          • Jun 2008
                          • 424

                          #13
                          Re: Seeking opinions from the peanut gallery

                          Thanks for the kind words. I am pretty sure this has become the centerpiece of my collection.

                          Comment

                          Working...