Who has the best player collection?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • project 4
    Senior Member
    • Jan 2011
    • 174

    Who has the best player collection?

    This is the only game used forum I know of so far (being relatively new) and seems to have a strong community of collectors here. I'm slowly making the switch from cards to memorabilia and in the card collecting community player PC's were huge. With that said I was wondering who has the best Player collection out there? I've seen some impressive items collected but like the challenge and focus of collecting one or two players.
  • spartanservitto
    Senior Member
    • May 2010
    • 932

    #2
    Re: Who has the best player collection?

    Bert has a solid Albert Pujols collection. Rich has THE best Austin Jackson collection.... I was never really a player focused collector, but I recently got into Alex Avila because he went to my high school and I believe has the most talent for a young catcher in the AL. Living in the area, I have quite a huge access to bats of his, so I decided to focus on photomatched home run bats. I've hit 4/4 on mine, and plan on continuing it in the 2012 season.

    Here are my oldest three, followed by the newest one I was able to purchase.
    Attached Files
    sigpic
    Always looking for ALEX AVILA, ALBERT PUJOLS, HOME RUN BATS, and any high end gamers from 90's-00's stars.

    Tony Servitto
    My Email: servitto84@yahoo.com
    My Website: http://vitosbatsandmemorabilia.webs.com/

    Comment

    • 2000mvpfan
      Senior Member
      • Nov 2005
      • 558

      #3
      Re: Who has the best player collection?

      LastingsMilledge85 has a great Milledge collection....me,it's all about the Giambis..



      Joe
      sigpic
      ...always looking for game-used JASON GIAMBI equipment!

      Comment

      • yankees506
        Senior Member
        • Apr 2010
        • 1064

        #4
        Re: Who has the best player collection?

        While cano has gotten big with collectors over the past year+ I'd throw my 15 Robbie bats and a few mis items out there with anyone.

        Comment

        • yankees506
          Senior Member
          • Apr 2010
          • 1064

          #5
          Re: Who has the best player collection?

          My Objective vote would go to rich (dach0sen0ne). His Austin Jackson collection is untouchable in every aspect possible. Www.austinjacksonfan.com

          Comment

          • Dewey2007
            Senior Member
            • Dec 2007
            • 2566

            #6
            Re: Who has the best player collection?

            Not the best but I've started a pretty decent Jimmy Rollins collection:

            4 bats (one of each brand: Max Bat, LVS, Adirondack, & Carolina Clubs, the Adirondack bat is photomatched to a homerun he hit in 2009)
            3 jerseys (2008 WS home jersey, 2009 WS road jersey, 2010 alternate)
            2 sets of batting gloves
            1 pair of cleats from the 2005 season
            2010 lineup card from game he hit is 150th career homerun
            2011 lineup card from game he hit is 100th career triple

            Waiting on a pair of road pants. Not sure what year they are from or if they are issued or worn so we'll see. Numerous other Rollins odds and ends to round out the collection.

            Always looking to add more especially a hat and wristbands...
            sigpicwww.alamedasportsproject.com

            Comment

            • danny_0_6
              Senior Member
              • Apr 2010
              • 179

              #7
              Re: Who has the best player collection?

              In my opinion I think Steve masi (masiman) has one of the better player collections on here. Being a Yankee fan and collector myself I thought his collection of Jorge posada bats was a great choice. Posada has one of the best looking bat characteristics in the game (tar,tape,cleat marks) I've been trying to catch up to Steve but it's been a tough task. Keep it up.....

              Mello (yanks506) your cano bats aren't too bad either. Lol

              Comment

              • spartanservitto
                Senior Member
                • May 2010
                • 932

                #8
                Re: Who has the best player collection?

                Originally posted by yankees506
                While cano has gotten big with collectors over the past year+ I'd throw my 15 Robbie bats and a few mis items out there with anyone.
                Your Cano collection is pretty unbelievable... a great player to invest in and follow. Do you have a website with your stuff posted!?!?!

                -Tony
                sigpic
                Always looking for ALEX AVILA, ALBERT PUJOLS, HOME RUN BATS, and any high end gamers from 90's-00's stars.

                Tony Servitto
                My Email: servitto84@yahoo.com
                My Website: http://vitosbatsandmemorabilia.webs.com/

                Comment

                • WadeInBmore
                  Senior Member
                  • Sep 2007
                  • 590

                  #9
                  Re: Who has the best player collection?

                  My Frank Thomas collection now has over 20 Gu bats (4 of which are hrs), 14 jerseys (sox, jays, and a's), 5 pair of pants, 3 nameplates, 5 Gu hats, 3 hr baseballs, 6 pairs of shoes, numerous batting gloves and wristbands, 2 Gu fielding gloves, and over 10 line up cards featuring the big hurt!!!!

                  Comment

                  • shoremen44
                    Senior Member
                    • Jul 2007
                    • 1161

                    #10
                    Re: Who has the best player collection?

                    spartanservitto... Bert has a solid Albert Pujols collection.
                    Tony... thanks... I think I have some nice bats, but I am sure there are much larger collections out there...

                    Wade's Thomas collection is just damn impressive...



                    I wont take first place, but I may have the best photo-match collection of one player...



                    Matt Wieters Collection....

                    16 Bats (12 Photomatched) 2 of them HR bats - and one with a LS shipping invoice

                    Minor League Jersey... Rookie Road Jersey (photomatched)... 1st All-Star Game BP jersey (photomatched)

                    Batting Helmet and catchers helmet (both Photomatched)
                    Bert
                    ---------------


                    Always looking for Matt Wieters, Tettleton, and that Orioles magic

                    shoremen44@gmail.com

                    Comment

                    • project 4
                      Senior Member
                      • Jan 2011
                      • 174

                      #11
                      Re: Who has the best player collection?

                      Originally posted by spartanservitto
                      Bert has a solid Albert Pujols collection. Rich has THE best Austin Jackson collection.... I was never really a player focused collector, but I recently got into Alex Avila because he went to my high school and I believe has the most talent for a young catcher in the AL. Living in the area, I have quite a huge access to bats of his, so I decided to focus on photomatched home run bats. I've hit 4/4 on mine, and plan on continuing it in the 2012 season.

                      Here are my oldest three, followed by the newest one I was able to purchase.
                      That is so neat that yall went to the same high school! Do you guys hang out? Do you get to get some stuff from him for free? Also, I'm realizing more and more that photomatching is huge here which leads me to this question: when you obtain your game used memorabilia, does it not come with a COA and the date of the game it was used? Or is photomatching just something done for fun? Thanks again for sharing!

                      Comment

                      • project 4
                        Senior Member
                        • Jan 2011
                        • 174

                        #12
                        Re: Who has the best player collection?

                        Originally posted by 2000mvpfan
                        LastingsMilledge85 has a great Milledge collection....me,it's all about the Giambis..



                        Joe
                        I think I've seen your Giambis before in some contest. You're the one who has the entire outfit from one game, right? That inspired me to get one of my own. I just have to figure out how to display it now. Very, Very nice collection by the way!

                        Originally posted by yankees506
                        While cano has gotten big with collectors over the past year+ I'd throw my 15 Robbie bats and a few mis items out there with anyone.
                        ALOT of bat collectors here! Are bats relatively inexpensive compared to other things like jerseys, cleats, etc?

                        Originally posted by Dewey2007
                        Not the best but I've started a pretty decent Jimmy Rollins collection:

                        4 bats (one of each brand: Max Bat, LVS, Adirondack, & Carolina Clubs, the Adirondack bat is photomatched to a homerun he hit in 2009)
                        3 jerseys (2008 WS home jersey, 2009 WS road jersey, 2010 alternate)
                        2 sets of batting gloves
                        1 pair of cleats from the 2005 season
                        2010 lineup card from game he hit is 150th career homerun
                        2011 lineup card from game he hit is 100th career triple

                        Waiting on a pair of road pants. Not sure what year they are from or if they are issued or worn so we'll see. Numerous other Rollins odds and ends to round out the collection.

                        Always looking to add more especially a hat and wristbands...
                        Hey, that's a sweet start to your collection. Where do you get your stuff?

                        Originally posted by danny_0_6
                        In my opinion I think Steve masi (masiman) has one of the better player collections on here. Being a Yankee fan and collector myself I thought his collection of Jorge posada bats was a great choice. Posada has one of the best looking bat characteristics in the game (tar,tape,cleat marks) I've been trying to catch up to Steve but it's been a tough task. Keep it up.....

                        Mello (yanks506) your cano bats aren't too bad either. Lol
                        I bet any yankee collection is hard to come by given the demand for their stuff. Quite an accomplishment. Thanks for sharing!

                        Originally posted by WadeInBmore
                        My Frank Thomas collection now has over 20 Gu bats (4 of which are hrs), 14 jerseys (sox, jays, and a's), 5 pair of pants, 3 nameplates, 5 Gu hats, 3 hr baseballs, 6 pairs of shoes, numerous batting gloves and wristbands, 2 Gu fielding gloves, and over 10 line up cards featuring the big hurt!!!!
                        Nice, I remember the big hurt back in the day. I was a huge Bagwell fan (still am) and remember that they shared the same birthday. I collected mainly Bagwell and Ken Griffey Jr but had a nice Frank Thomas collection on the side back when I collected cards in the 90's. I remember being in pursuit of his Topps Error (no name) Rc at one point bc I envisioned him breaking the home run record one day. Such a talent. Thanks for sharing!

                        Originally posted by shoremen44
                        Tony... thanks... I think I have some nice bats, but I am sure there are much larger collections out there...

                        Wade's Thomas collection is just damn impressive...



                        I wont take first place, but I may have the best photo-match collection of one player...



                        Matt Wieters Collection....

                        16 Bats (12 Photomatched) 2 of them HR bats - and one with a LS shipping invoice

                        Minor League Jersey... Rookie Road Jersey (photomatched)... 1st All-Star Game BP jersey (photomatched)

                        Batting Helmet and catchers helmet (both Photomatched)
                        Really nice! Is Matt Wieters a future prospect? Sorry, I don't know too much about the players anymore. I was talking to this guy who works at a memorabila store and he mentioned how players that aren't proven don't get as much attention in the world of memorabilia vs established players. I'm learning it's so different from card collecting b/c it's all about prospecting. I'm also realizing that baseball dominates here! I was a huge fan back in the 90's but after the strike it left a bad taste in my mouth. I moved on to football and starting to collect some stuff for my future man cave. At least I will be able to show them off instead of keeping them hidden in the dark like my football cards.

                        Keep them coming! Also, would love to see some football PC! =)

                        Comment

                        • Dach0sen0ne
                          Senior Member
                          • Jul 2010
                          • 872

                          #13
                          Re: Who has the best player collection?

                          Originally posted by 2000mvpfan
                          LastingsMilledge85 has a great Milledge collection
                          +1

                          LastingsMilledge85 has a great collection! Check it out!

                          Comment

                          • yankees506
                            Senior Member
                            • Apr 2010
                            • 1064

                            #14
                            Re: Who has the best player collection?

                            Originally posted by spartanservitto
                            Your Cano collection is pretty unbelievable... a great player to invest in and follow. Do you have a website with your stuff posted!?!?!

                            -Tony
                            Thanks tony, I'm always checking out your site. I did purchase a domain name a while back but have no idea where to get started, hopefully that will change soon.

                            To answer a question asked by the original poster, bats run the gammit from relatively inexpensive to insanely priced, as high as 10k for star vintage Players such as mante and mays. Modern plays can run from a hundred or less for lesser known players. To a few hundred for stars or even thousands for the top guys pujols, jeter etc....

                            Comment

                            • Dach0sen0ne
                              Senior Member
                              • Jul 2010
                              • 872

                              #15
                              Re: Who has the best player collection?

                              Originally posted by yankees506
                              My Objective vote would go to rich (dach0sen0ne). His Austin Jackson collection is untouchable in every aspect possible. Www.austinjacksonfan.com
                              Thanks Melo! That Cano collection isn't too shabby! We need to get working on your site.

                              Comment

                              Working...