Picked up a Brant Brown bat in a Phoenix thrift shop for $3.99. I didn't even know who BB was at the time, but it offended me that anybody's gamer was sitting on a thrift shop shelf with a bunch of crap. Later sold it to another board member for what I paid + postage, who ended up mailing it back to me to get it signed during the Fall League.

Speaking of Fall League, I paid $34.95 for the jersey Chris Speier wore while managing the Scottsdale Scorpions in 1998. The lady who was selling it on eBay had no clue it was a gamer - thought it was just a souvenier, and had it listed under Used Clothing.