2 Home Run Baseballs - Which Would You Sell? Which Would You Keep?

[suave1477]

Dear Members I would like all of your opinions.

If you had 2 post season home runs hit by the same player

Home Run (A) was a game winning Home Run

Home Run (B) was hit off a future hall of famer

Which would you keep and which would you sell?

[mdube16]

with all other things being equal (authenticity, importance of the game ect) I would want the game winning HR

[joelsabi]

Dear Members I would like all of your opinions.

If you had 2 post season home runs hit by the same player

Home Run (A) was a game winning Home Run

Home Run (B) was hit off a future hall of famer

Which would you keep and which would you sell?

i would go with the game winning home run too.

[orioles03]

i have two home run balls im trying to sell one was not a game winning hr but mine is of arod #16 of 2003 season and #314 of career
then another was brian roberts hit off pedro on jackie robinson day off pedro martinez in 2004 has jackie robinson logo on ball in my opininon i would keep the game winning hr
orioles03@verizon.net if you want to see pics i'm not to fanmilar on posting pics

[Sheffield11]

It seems like everyone would want the HR ball, so for that reason i would sell it because it will clearly go for a lot more money.

[earlywynnfan]

Is the hitter a stud player, or average? If it's Manny Ramirez hitting these, I'd be tempted by the Game Winner. But if it's Casey Blake, I'd take the ball hit off the HOF pitcher, ESPECIALLY if the pitcher still won the game.

Ken

[skyking26]

I'd keep the one that was a GW HR ball. I'd sell the one hit of the HOF'er - because who cares...

[tigerdale]

Yep, Keep The Game Winner....but If They're Both Post Season Home Runs, You Can't Go Wrong....so Is This A True Question??
I Collect Home Run Balls, But A Post Season One Would Be Awesome!!!

[suave1477]

Thanks everyone!!!

If anyone else has anything to add please do.

Earlywynn the hitter I guess can be considered a semi star

Tigerdale yes this is a true question and both balls come directly from the player with an LOA
If you are interested you can contact me suave1477@yahoo.com

[c5212]

Keep the game winner- not a question in my mind