i bought a case of 12 and took 6 and sold 6. when they left my hands they were in top shape. is it possible the fedex dropped them, yes. is it probable, no.
since he deals in these, there is no doubt in my mind that he swapped his bad ones for my good ones to sell them for more money because he told me that he couldn't sell them unless they were mint. now he is trying to stiff me for a refund and to pay him to ship them back!!! what a shyster. and threatening me too!