PSA/DNA or MLB Holo?

[spartakid]

I'm looking for your opinion because my brother ad I are having an arguement. I say PSA is better becuase they have pics and they are well documented. He says MLB is better because they get them straight from the players. Your opinions?

[Fnazxc0114]

mlb because it comes from the source. granted their holo's arent updated as well as i like. psa is nothing more than some guys oppinion to authenticity whereas mlb theres no opinion at all

[AWA85]

MLB all the way, has a stronger backing behind the name.


If only they had their database always working where the holograms showed up though, but that is a whole different issue.

[mariner_gamers]

In my opinion MLB.

[Vintagedeputy]

I dont trust anything that PSA does.

[kylehess10]

I say the MLB hologram. Atleast it tells you exactly when the piece was used. PSA/DNA can't do that, plus they can make a lot of mistakes easily. If a bat was used by a player other than the name on the barrel, the MLB hologram will sometimes state that; now unless there are specific characteristics that prove a bat not to be used by a specific player, then PSA/DNA can't prove that

[Tedw9]

Sorry to say, but your brother is right.

PSA is just an opinion. They have one, I have one, you have one, we all have one. But are they all right? No.

Where as MLB only authenticates what it sees. There is NO question about MLB holograms, they are rock solid. No opinions there, just the facts.

So to answer your question, would you rather have an item that someone has told you they think is authentic or an item that someone has told you is guaranteed to be authentic?

[thrush29]

Chalk another one up for MLB. The 08 jerseys (3) I have recieved so far this year have all been in the system and game specific.

[b.heagy]

PSA/DNA for vintage - MLB for current

[Rob L]

Definitely MLB.