I may be missing something, but if the seller lied about the source of the item, then there is misrepresentation. The source of the item can directly dictate the fair market value of the item (Overpriced NFL Auctions). If the seller claimed it came from a clubhouse source and has documentation to support such source, then told her it came from a dealer after the fact, the credibility of the item has been diminished and therefore it's value. Clearly she overpaid for the item, but if it was based on false pretenses because of the advertised source, then there should be some accountability.