Ot: Neutral 3rd Party Authenticator - Need Help !!!!

[jordan23collectibles]

Fellow GUU Members,

I would like to ask for your help if possible.

I have a 10K item that was reviewed by 2 well known authograph authenticators (PSA/DNA and JSA) and both have different opinions on the piece.

Who do I go to for a NEUTRAL 3rd Party Authenticator that can help in situations like this?

Any help is appreciated.

jordan23collectibles

[schubert1970]

Re: Ot: Neutral 3rd Party Authenticator - Need Help !!!!

Fellow GUU Members,

I would like to ask for your help if possible.

I have a 10K item that was reviewed by 2 well known authograph authenticators (PSA/DNA and JSA) and both have different opinions on the piece.

Who do I go to for a NEUTRAL 3rd Party Authenticator that can help in situations like this?

Any help is appreciated.

jordan23collectibles

Lou Lampson

[Texans]

Re: Ot: Neutral 3rd Party Authenticator - Need Help !!!!

Post up the autograph


Jojo

[jordan23collectibles]

Re: Ot: Neutral 3rd Party Authenticator - Need Help !!!!

Lou Lampson

I was asking for help and not a sarcastic remark.

Just wondering if this is how you treat new members in the forum asking for help?

[TriplexXxSports]

Re: Ot: Neutral 3rd Party Authenticator - Need Help !!!!

It would help if you posted a pic of the piece, as well as the signature. There are different experts in different fields. It would to know what we are dealing with here.

[jordan23collectibles]

Re: Ot: Neutral 3rd Party Authenticator - Need Help !!!!

It would help if you posted a pic of the piece, as well as the signature. There are different experts in different fields. It would to know what we are dealing with here.

To Texans/TriplexXxSports - thanks for the responses.

Here is the item (72-10 Chicago Bulls Banner)

[otismalibu]

Re: Ot: Neutral 3rd Party Authenticator - Need Help !!!!

Is 10K what you paid for the item, or is that the selling price?

Just curious.

[jordan23collectibles]

Re: Ot: Neutral 3rd Party Authenticator - Need Help !!!!

Is 10K what you paid for the item, or is that the selling price?

Just curious.

Greg,

10K+ was the selling price for this item.

jordan23collectibles

[otismalibu]

Re: Ot: Neutral 3rd Party Authenticator - Need Help !!!!

10K+ was the selling price for this item.

Gotcha.

Thanks.

[spartakid]

Re: Ot: Neutral 3rd Party Authenticator - Need Help !!!!

I was asking for help and not a sarcastic remark.

Just wondering if this is how you treat new members in the forum asking for help?

Come on man, that was funny. I think the two you've already consulated are the two big ones. I can't really think of a third reputable company. Ricardo

[jordan23collectibles]

Re: Ot: Neutral 3rd Party Authenticator - Need Help !!!!

Come on man, that was funny. I think the two you've already consulated are the two big ones. I can't really think of a third reputable company. Ricardo

Ricardo,

I really value other GUU members opinion, that is why I asked this question.

I hope other GUU members can help me find an arbitrator besides these 2 companies that can be neutral and can have an independent assessment on this item.

jordan23collectibles

[mdube16]

Re: Ot: Neutral 3rd Party Authenticator - Need Help !!!!

Richard Simon knows his stuff.

http://about-autograph-collecting.com/authentication.htm

[Texans]

Re: Ot: Neutral 3rd Party Authenticator - Need Help !!!!

That Jordan autograph is hard to tell. You took the auto to the major authenticators out there. Which one rejected the auto? Is the seller reliable?


Jojo

[TriplexXxSports]

Re: Ot: Neutral 3rd Party Authenticator - Need Help !!!!

Anyone know if UDA would look this over? I would check into them. I know there gold when it comes to MJ auto's. I don't know about the others though.

[worldchamps]

Re: Ot: Neutral 3rd Party Authenticator - Need Help !!!!

I think it was Steve Ryan, North Shore auctions, who used to have a lot of these signed banners...i would look at some of the other autographs and make an opinion on it, the Ron Harper, Pippen, Jack Haley, etc....to me it doesnt look good

All the autographs are the same size and going in the same direction...

My opinion for what it is worth is I would not buy it. But dont go off the authenicators, do your homework on what other signatures look like and compare and contrast.