I concur with contacting the club directly (find out the name of the ticket manager and write him/her directly). Back when Ripken was playing and hit a HR, I'd drop a sincere, brief letter in the mail (offerring to pay) and my success rate was probably 90%........If you PM or email me, I can get you the name of the Reds ticket manager in this situation.

Bill
whhp72@yahoo.com