which one of these is Worth More. I would really like your Opinions !

[Jays1fan]

which one of these is Worth More. I would really like your Opinions !

2007 Roy Halladay TEAM ISSUED Autographed Jersey with MLB Hologram
Hologram number BB587217 was located in the MLB Authentication Database under JERSEYS.
Session Product Description: SIGNED JERSEY
Session Name: BOSTON RED SOX @ TORONTO BLUE JAYS
Session Date: September 17, 2007
Autographer: ROY HALLADAY
Authenticator: AUTHENTICATORS, INC.
Additional Information: ROY HALLADAY TEAM ISSUED JERSEY (32 07 S3)


OR

2006 Lyle Overbay GAME USED Jersey with MLB Hologram
Hologram number BB024745 was located in the MLB Authentication Database under JERSEYS.
Session Product Description: GAME USED JERSEY
Session Name: TORONTO BLUE JAYS?@?NEW YORK YANKEES
Session Date: September 29, 2006
Autographer:
Authenticator: AUTHENTICATORS, INC.
Additional Information: #35 LYLE OVERBAY

[centerfieldsports.com]

Doc for sure, does it show any use?
The reason i ask is i got two jerseys from last season that come up issued right from the blue jays and they are HAMMERED with use, the bluejays rep i bought them from said they tried to get them changed in the system but it was to late

[Jays1fan]

I am no expert when it comes to that On Jerseys. There is a small smudge type mark around where the Pants would be if he was wearing it. And when comparing it to my "Game Used" jerseys they look the same to me.
If you send me your email , I can send you close up pictures if you want.
Thanks for the Imput .. I do appreciate that !

[joelsabi]

overbay is from a game used session and the halladay from a autograph session. i would say the overbay.

[Jays1fan]

overbay is from a game used session and the halladay from a autograph session. i would say the overbay.

At first I had thought the same since the Jays have a Couple of 2006 Overbay Game Jerseys for sale on their website at $400 ( but they charge $40-$50 ) for shipping. Then got a couple of Emails saying the Halladay was worth $750 - $1000. Think I will see if the Jays have any Halladay Jerseys at all for sale. Maybe that might be a better guide line.
I do appreciate your Thoughts.
Scott

[schubert1970]

I liked the game used stuff. Too many of the game issued autographed items exist.

[sugarpam]

At first I had thought the same since the Jays have a Couple of 2006 Overbay Game Jerseys for sale on their website at $400 ( but they charge $40-$50 ) for shipping. Then got a couple of Emails saying the Halladay was worth $750 - $1000. Think I will see if the Jays have any Halladay Jerseys at all for sale. Maybe that might be a better guide line.
I do appreciate your Thoughts.
Scott

Scott,

I picked up a 2007 Game Used Halladay jersey from the Jays website earlier this season for $800 if that helps at all.

-Pam