I'm curious on everyones thoughts on this.

Say you see two game used broken bats from your favorite player. Both are MLB authenticated.

Both show equal use.

One was broken off a rookie pitcher that nobody has heard of.

The other is broken off a star pitcher. Say C.C. Sabathia or Johan Santana.


The bat broken against the star pitcher costs...say $50 more.




Does it matter to you who the pitcher was? Would you stick with the cheaper bat, or buy the more expensive one which came off a star pitcher?