Kyle...

For me the opposing pitcher doesn't matter. Knowing whoever threw the pitch that resulted in the player breaking the bat is a bonus IMO. I don't think there are any legendary matchups in the baseball world a-la Ali Frazier (arguable is Piazza Clemens ). Chances are if the bat filled a hole in my collection and I could get it for 50 bucks cheaper I would go for IT.

What's your take? You posed the question but didn't answer it yourself. I know that you like to photomatch...but does it really matter to you. It adds a level of intrigue sure, but is it necessarily significant and does it add that much more value?

wade