any ideas on who this is?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • OaklandAsFan
    Senior Member
    • Sep 2007
    • 745

    any ideas on who this is?

    Friend of mine came across this bat but no clue who it is. any thoughts? There is a 7 written on the end of the knob if that helps and it has the MLB logo between the centerbrand and the name stamp to help date it.

    thanks in advance

  • LastingsMilledge85
    Senior Member
    • May 2009
    • 1438

    #2
    Re: any ideas on who this is?

    My guess would be Bobby Crosby, but I bet I'm wrong.

    Comment

    • Manram
      Senior Member
      • Nov 2008
      • 1151

      #3
      Re: any ideas on who this is?

      Do you have a time frame of what years it could be from? I know you said it is signature engraved, but does it have some stamp or something?

      Comment

      • WadeInBmore
        Senior Member
        • Sep 2007
        • 590

        #4
        Re: any ideas on who this is?

        Originally posted by OaklandAsFan
        Friend of mine came across this bat but no clue who it is. any thoughts? There is a 7 written on the end of the knob if that helps and it has the MLB logo between the centerbrand and the name stamp to help date it.

        thanks in advance

        Hmmm...here are the players that used that number
        Frank Menechino (1999)
        Jeremy Giambi
        Bobby Crosby
        Kurt Abbott (1998)
        Scott Brosius (1997)
        Mike Kingery (1992)
        1991 wasn't issued to anyone
        Walt Weiss (1990)
        Jerry Willard (1986)
        Charlie O'Brien (1985)
        Mike Edwards (1980)
        Rick Bosetti (1981)
        Dan Meyer (1983)
        in 1984 it wasn't issued in the bigs.

        probably too much info...but with out a narrower set of dates that the bat could be from I bid you good luck and I hope it helps.

        wade

        Comment

        • scootmagroot
          Senior Member
          • Oct 2009
          • 258

          #5
          Re: any ideas on who this is?

          I say its probably a minor leaguer. definitely isn't Crosby.

          Comment

          • Manram
            Senior Member
            • Nov 2008
            • 1151

            #6
            Re: any ideas on who this is?

            Originally posted by scootmagroot
            I say its probably a minor leaguer. definitely isn't Crosby.
            After reading through the players, i agree

            Comment

            • TNTtoys
              Moderator
              • Aug 2006
              • 2618

              #7
              Re: any ideas on who this is?

              Originally posted by WadeInBmore
              Hmmm...here are the players that used that number
              Frank Menechino (1999)
              Jeremy Giambi
              Bobby Crosby
              Kurt Abbott (1998)
              Scott Brosius (1997)
              Mike Kingery (1992)
              1991 wasn't issued to anyone
              Walt Weiss (1990)
              Jerry Willard (1986)
              Charlie O'Brien (1985)
              Mike Edwards (1980)
              Rick Bosetti (1981)
              Dan Meyer (1983)
              in 1984 it wasn't issued in the bigs.

              probably too much info...but with out a narrower set of dates that the bat could be from I bid you good luck and I hope it helps.

              wade
              In an attempt to narrow down Wade's list, team names (as seen in the photo) were added to the barrel of Louisville Slugger bats in 1991.

              This leaves only the following as possibilities:

              Frank Menechino (1999)
              Jeremy Giambi
              Bobby Crosby
              Kurt Abbott (1998)
              Scott Brosius (1997)
              Mike Kingery (1992)

              Unless we're talking about a minor leaguer, as previously hypothesized in the thread.
              Looking for ...
              Any Game Used Mets jerseys from 1986 and 1987
              Any Keith Hernandez, Ron Darling, Lee Mazzilli and John Olerud Mets items
              Email me at TNT_Toys@yahoo.com

              Comment

              • legaleagle92481
                Banned
                • Oct 2009
                • 2538

                #8
                Re: any ideas on who this is?

                Originally posted by TNTtoys
                In an attempt to narrow down Wade's list, team names (as seen in the photo) were added to the barrel of Louisville Slugger bats in 1991.

                This leaves only the following as possibilities:

                Frank Menechino (1999)
                Jeremy Giambi
                Bobby Crosby
                Kurt Abbott (1998)
                Scott Brosius (1997)
                Mike Kingery (1992)

                Unless we're talking about a minor leaguer, as previously hypothesized in the thread.
                I am going to guess it is Frank Menechino to me the first letter looks like an F and the last an O.

                Comment

                • AthleticsFan
                  Member
                  • Mar 2007
                  • 94

                  #9
                  Re: any ideas on who this is?

                  Originally posted by legaleagle92481
                  I am going to guess it is Frank Menechino to me the first letter looks like an F and the last an O.
                  It definitely is not Frank Menechino, Bobby Crosby, Scott Brosius or Jeremy Giambi.

                  Comment

                  • jetersbatboy
                    Senior Member
                    • Jun 2008
                    • 1903

                    #10
                    Re: any ideas on who this is?

                    From the labeling described it sounds like a 1999-2001 era bat. So only Jermey Giambi and Frank Menechino wore the number 7 during the time period. It was Frank in 99 and Jeremy in 2000-01. Due to that fact and the look of the signature, I would say Frank.

                    Comment

                    • AthleticsFan
                      Member
                      • Mar 2007
                      • 94

                      #11
                      Re: any ideas on who this is?

                      Jeremy Giambi wore #7 during his time with the A's from 2000 to May 2002. While Frank Menechino might have worn #7 during Spring Training in 2000, he always wore #11 during the regular season.

                      Getting back to the bat, I still can't figure out whose signature that is but it is possible that one of the #7's on the list borrowed the bat from the mystery player.

                      Comment

                      • OaklandAsFan
                        Senior Member
                        • Sep 2007
                        • 745

                        #12
                        Re: any ideas on who this is?

                        I can tell everyone without a doubt that it is not Menechino. I have dozens of his autograph. I am starting to think that maybe it was borrowed and used by mini G. I was hoping maybe someone here recognized the signature.

                        Comment

                        • joelsabi
                          Senior Member
                          • Aug 2005
                          • 3073

                          #13
                          Re: any ideas on who this is?

                          Originally posted by OaklandAsFan
                          I can tell everyone without a doubt that it is not Menechino. I have dozens of his autograph. I am starting to think that maybe it was borrowed and used by mini G. I was hoping maybe someone here recognized the signature.
                          The person had to have a contract with LVS since the name is not in block letters. The center brand should be 1999-2001.

                          i go to http://www.baseball-reference.com/
                          I look up on the team tab and look for Oakland links for 1999 and 2001.
                          I copy the players who had at least 1 ab on a spreadsheet for those three years
                          I remove all duplicate names. (create a column, scan put an X on duplicate names, sort and delete 1 minute max)

                          So here are the suspects:

                          A.J. Hinch
                          Adam Piatt
                          Andy Abad*
                          Ariel Prieto
                          Barry Zito*
                          Ben Grieve*
                          Billy McMillon*
                          Bo Porter
                          Cory Lidle
                          Eric Byrnes
                          Eric Chavez*
                          F.P. Santangelo#
                          Frank Menechino
                          Gil Heredia
                          Greg Myers*
                          Jason Giambi*
                          Jason McDonald#
                          Jeremy Giambi*
                          Jermaine Dye
                          Jimmy Haynes
                          John Jaha
                          Johnny Damon*
                          Jorge Velandia
                          Jose Ortiz
                          Kenny Rogers*
                          Kevin Appier
                          Marcus Jones
                          Mario Valdez*
                          Mark Bellhorn#
                          Mark Mulder*
                          Matt Stairs*
                          Miguel Tejada
                          Mike Macfarlane
                          Mike Magnante*
                          Mike Stanley
                          Olmedo Saenz
                          Omar Olivares
                          Ramon Hernandez
                          Randy Velarde
                          Rich Becker*
                          Rob Ryan*
                          Robin Jennings*
                          Ron Gant
                          Ryan Christenson
                          Sal Fasano
                          Scott Spiezio#
                          Terrence Long*
                          Tim Hudson
                          Tim Raines#
                          Tom Wilson
                          Tony Phillips#
                          Regards,
                          Joel S.
                          joelsabi @ gmail.com
                          Wanted: Alex Rodriguez Game Used Items and other unique artifacts, 1992 thru 1998 only. From High School to Early Mariners.

                          Comment

                          • joelsabi
                            Senior Member
                            • Aug 2005
                            • 3073

                            #14
                            Re: any ideas on who this is?

                            My next step would be to scan the list and see if any of the names looks like the name on the bat and then go to ebay and compare autograph for those players. If it's not a match I put a NO on a new VERIFIED column on the spreadsheet and go to the next suspect. If there are no sigs on ebay to compare then I google the name and use the photo link looking for signed baseballs and photos.

                            Good luck on the mystery. This is my process for looking up names on Team signed baseballs.


                            Originally posted by joelsabi
                            The person had to have a contract with LVS since the name is not in block letters. The center brand should be 1999-2001.

                            i go to http://www.baseball-reference.com/
                            I look up on the team tab and look for Oakland links for 1999 and 2001.
                            I copy the players who had at least 1 ab on a spreadsheet for those three years
                            I remove all duplicate names. (create a column, scan put an X on duplicate names, sort and delete 1 minute max)

                            So here are the suspects:

                            A.J. Hinch
                            Adam Piatt
                            Andy Abad*
                            Ariel Prieto
                            Barry Zito*
                            Ben Grieve*
                            Billy McMillon*
                            Bo Porter
                            Cory Lidle
                            Eric Byrnes
                            Eric Chavez*
                            F.P. Santangelo#
                            Frank Menechino
                            Gil Heredia
                            Greg Myers*
                            Jason Giambi*
                            Jason McDonald#
                            Jeremy Giambi*
                            Jermaine Dye
                            Jimmy Haynes
                            John Jaha
                            Johnny Damon*
                            Jorge Velandia
                            Jose Ortiz
                            Kenny Rogers*
                            Kevin Appier
                            Marcus Jones
                            Mario Valdez*
                            Mark Bellhorn#
                            Mark Mulder*
                            Matt Stairs*
                            Miguel Tejada
                            Mike Macfarlane
                            Mike Magnante*
                            Mike Stanley
                            Olmedo Saenz
                            Omar Olivares
                            Ramon Hernandez
                            Randy Velarde
                            Rich Becker*
                            Rob Ryan*
                            Robin Jennings*
                            Ron Gant
                            Ryan Christenson
                            Sal Fasano
                            Scott Spiezio#
                            Terrence Long*
                            Tim Hudson
                            Tim Raines#
                            Tom Wilson
                            Tony Phillips#
                            Regards,
                            Joel S.
                            joelsabi @ gmail.com
                            Wanted: Alex Rodriguez Game Used Items and other unique artifacts, 1992 thru 1998 only. From High School to Early Mariners.

                            Comment

                            • OaklandAsFan
                              Senior Member
                              • Sep 2007
                              • 745

                              #15
                              Re: any ideas on who this is?

                              I certainly appreciate all that work and effort Joel. None of those names seem to coincide with even a hint of that signature though. Must be someone under contract with LVS that never made the show. hmmmmm

                              Comment

                              Working...