Your best bet is to hire a lawyer who practices in Washington State to file a small claims court lawsuit. Yes it will cost you some money but it is a simple case so it won't cost you all that much. You likely won't get your legal fees back but chalk it up as a lesson in if something sounds true good to be true it probably is. $1,425 is crazy cheap for a real Ichiro gamer, esp. one that is autographed. You can find the lawyer by googling Bar Associations near Renton Washington. Give one close to there a call and they will refer you to someone free of charge. The authorities will do nothing over $1,425, most of the time or if they do it will take forever for them to act sports memorabilia fraud is not a huge concern of theirs unless it is on a very, very large scale.