Huge Question on a pair of Votto Fielding Gloves from 2006

[rchimes13@yahoo.com]

I have been searching for a game used Joey Votto glove for a little over a year. In the last month or so I have come across 5 different gloves. One way over priced, 2 that look to be back-up gloves that are signed "game used" , and two from 2006. Here's my concern...both the 2006 gloves come signed and inscribed (COA via Lockeroom Memorabilia) "Game Used 2006 Futures Game"and both gloves are hammered with use...I find it really hard to believe he switched gloves during the game (only played 4 innings in field) and only pics I can find look like he's wearing same glove. I've attached a pic of each glove...would love to hear what you guys think. I would hate to drop big $ on a glove that has ?'s concerning when it was used and why an inscription was duplicated.