Trading memorabilia to a player?

[moo5100@yahoo.com]

I just became aware that my Oakland Athletics Chris Carter jersey is the one he wore during his first homerun. It is authenticated to the day after, but it was photomatched it to the homer (MLB Authentication error). Anyways, do you think he would want this jersey being that it could be pretty significant to him? I would gladly trade it if he wanted to, also what should i ask for?

[rdeversole]

Re: Trading memorabilia to a player?

I would think that if he had wanted it that it would've never made it to market for sale. Probably not the same significance to him as say his first MLB jersey worn.

[moo5100@yahoo.com]

Re: Trading memorabilia to a player?

I thought the same thing, but maybe he didnt think about it at the time or something. Worth a shot.

[scootmagroot]

Re: Trading memorabilia to a player?

I spoke with James Darnell of the Padres quite a bit at spring training since I have the jersey he wore when hitting his first MLB homerun. He offered me a few things and seemed genuinely interested in having it, but I was asking him for a glove. We came to the agreement that we would talk in September when he is up for the end of the year. I will be pushing for a glove.

[r_phelps]

Re: Trading memorabilia to a player?

Sounds like something he would really appreciate later in life but I would offer if given the opportunity.

[Skizzick]

Re: Trading memorabilia to a player?

Maybe take the opportunity to trade up. Ask for a Cespedes jersey if he has access to one.

[moo5100@yahoo.com]

Re: Trading memorabilia to a player?

I was honestly thinking that exact thing. A Cespedes jersey would be amazing. He just needs the call up first

[OaklandAsFan]

Re: Trading memorabilia to a player?

I think that would be insulting IMO. "hey i've got this great game used jersey of yours but I'd gladly give it up for a better one of a guy who may have greater value than yours"

Your best bet is to see if he wants it and try and work something out of equal value to both of you.

[sox83cubs84]

Re: Trading memorabilia to a player?

I think that would be insulting IMO. "hey i've got this great game used jersey of yours but I'd gladly give it up for a better one of a guy who may have greater value than yours"

Your best bet is to see if he wants it and try and work something out of equal value to both of you.

I totally agree. +1

Dave Miedema

[Mulligans]

Re: Trading memorabilia to a player?

In my Opinion, the whole process seems a bit tacky? I can see offering up a Jersey to a player expecting nothing in return and hoping that I make the guys day.

Maybe he would feel the kindness to take care of you in some way?

If I were a player and someone contacted me to trade or buy a Jersey I'd think the guy was a total Loser......No I'm not calling you a loser....Just sharing my personal feelings with you.

[OaklandAsFan]

Re: Trading memorabilia to a player?

Mulligans I think it depends on the situation.

For example I have Ryan Roberts pink mothers day cleats from last season, I have heard from several people that he is upset that they were taken from his locker without consulting him right after the game as he wanted to give them to his mother. I think in that situation making a trade is a good thing and if I ever happen to run into him prior to a game I will be discussing a trade with him.

Maybe Chris would like the jersey and it was removed before he had a chance to grab it, who knows. I don't see any harm in asking, worst case is he will say no thanks keep it..

[jbsportstuff]

Re: Trading memorabilia to a player?

Very interesting reads. I'm positive that most guys don't have access to other players jerseys. Often players can get stuff signed by other players, but most don't have access to their jerseys.

I have Devin Mesoraco's MLB debut jersey. He confirmed it as such after I photo matched it and showed it to him. He ended up signing it as MLB Debut jersey. I offered him the jersey and he said that he might be interested. Nothing has happened since.

[moo5100@yahoo.com]

Re: Trading memorabilia to a player?

That was the other thing that i was thinking and why I asked everyone. But he has to realize that I paid for it. I might maybe throw out the idea of a Cespedes jersey jokingly, just to see what he would say, but not expecting it at all. Maybe he would do it for a different jersey and a helmet or something? I would feel weird asking for much more than that

[Tyrcha]

Re: Trading memorabilia to a player?

Just wanted to add my experience...

I acquired Stephen Paea's jersey in which he recorded his first career sack. I happened to also be following him on Twitter at the time. Just for the fun of it I tweeted him a picture of the jersey and he imidiately responded with, "Can I buy that from you?". I went back and fourth with him for a little while and we ended up meeting. We agreed on a trade, he got his first sack jersey and I got his signed practice jersey, his signed/issued London jersey and a pair of gloves. He's a really cool guy and I've since seen the jersey I traded him framed in a photo he posted. Pretty cool experience. Good luck with your situation!

[Klattsy]

Re: Trading memorabilia to a player?

I've gone the opposite way a couple of times. I gave one player a heap of his own trading cards once and he gave me a great deal when he was selling off items on eBay and another guy I am trading a heap of cards of his favorite player for a pair of cleats. Thats the great thing about Aussie players is they are so accessible (local ball parks or Twitter).