Well first I would make sure which one is undoubtly a photomatch. Meaning not looks similar "SAME"

I have seen people say well this is a photomatch and the marks are similar but not exact. So first make sure you are able to distinctly photomatch both.

Once that said I would say next what is your appeal to the player. Is he your favorite player? Is he just a player you like? Do you like significant values on items in your collection suach as a walk off home run, a game winning touch down.

Then decide from there If hes your favorite, try to get both, If you like items with heavy use get the more heavier one, if you like items that attribute to something get that one.

If you can have a heavy game used mckey mantle bat or a slight used mantle home run bat which would you go for???