Opinion needed FAST Frank Thomas yearbook

[stasman]

Okay members. I need your opinions... Tomorrow I will be meeting Frank Thomas for an autograph. I have his High School yearbook and his college yearbook. Which would be best for this HOF'er to sign??

Matt

[BU54CB]

I would say neither, but I guess HS if I had to choose.

[frikativ54]

I admittedly have a few different Bagwell HS yearbooks, but honestly, if I were the player, I'd be a little creeped out. It feels kind of stalkerish, in a way. It's really cool to have them, because there are little-known statistics and photos in some of the yearbooks. Yet, if I were in an athlete's position, I'd be kind of weirded out.

[emann]

I'd vote college.

The high school one only if you can get him to write "have a cool summer!"

[salukidave]

High school, for sure.

[GoTigers]

College, it appeals to a whole other fan base. I'd like to have an Auburn yearbook signed by Frank, but have no desire for a High School yearbook of his.

[bgakladd]

I would go with college. I have a lot of Chris Spielman high school items, signed photos, yearbook, trophies, programs and calendars his parents marked on and his varsity letter from his Massillon Tigers days but I think his college days at Ohio State would have more appeal for me if I had them, even a yearbook. So again I say college.

[Phil316]

I would not get either. Sorry I add nothing.

[PAC]

NEITHER

It would be cool to have a (insert player here) high school yearbook with his HIGH SCHOOL ERA SIGNATURE
or a (insert player here) college yearbook with his COLLEGE ERA SIGNATURE

but a high school or college yearbook with a fresh new signature from a 45 year-old man...pass

[bravesfanjd]

I would get college because Auburn is famous in its own right also you find find other famous athletes in the book and could add to the autographs over time