Why is Arod really hate by so many people?

[3arod13]

Hope they keep both. Cano and Melky underperformed.

If they trade any of them for pitching i am for it.

Definately time for Giambi to go. Doesn't give much at 1st base. Low batting average and he's only good for a few HR's here and there.

[whatupyos]

Definately time for Giambi to go. Doesn't give much at 1st base. Low batting average and he's only good for a few HR's here and there.

I understand you're pro- ARod, but I think thats a huge knock on Giambi. Yes, you're right, ARod had a better AVE. but the power numbers are too close to say "...he's only good for a few HR's here and there".


Ave. HR's RBI's AB's Walks K's

ARod's 2008 stats .302 35 103 510 65 117
Giambi's 2008 stats .247 32 96 458 76 111


Giambi's only 3 HR's away with 52 less officical AB's. Only 7 RBI's away with less K's. So, if you're going to knock Giambi, I think its a little unfair since he was close to ARod in the HR's and RBI's plus K's less.

[kellsox]

Definately time for Giambi to go. Doesn't give much at 1st base. Low batting average and he's only good for a few HR's here and there.

2007 HR's
A Rod 35
Giambi 32

Also, Arod's OBP was only about 20 points higher

[kellsox]

Sorry...2008 HR totals

[3arod13]

I understand you're pro- ARod, but I think thats a huge knock on Giambi. Yes, you're right, ARod had a better AVE. but the power numbers are too close to say "...he's only good for a few HR's here and there".


Ave. HR's RBI's AB's Walks K's

ARod's 2008 stats .302 35 103 510 65 117
Giambi's 2008 stats .247 32 96 458 76 111


Giambi's only 3 HR's away with 52 less officical AB's. Only 7 RBI's away with less K's. So, if you're going to knock Giambi, I think its a little unfair since he was close to ARod in the HR's and RBI's plus K's less.

You forgot to add that Arod was out for a month. Give him those games bat and he's got 45 HR's and 125 RBI's

[joelsabi]

Definately time for Giambi to go. Doesn't give much at 1st base. Low batting average and he's only good for a few HR's here and there.

Giambi is still productive. Hes second on the team in hr and third in rbis. Time for him to go? Dont think so.

[3arod13]

Giambi is still productive. Hes second on the team in hr and third in rbis. Time for him to go? Dont think so.

Ok, I give up!

[whatupyos]

I don't care if he was out half the year. The numbers don't lie. If he's out 1 week or 6 weeks the AB's are close, the numbers too close to judge. You're making a huge assumption that AROd would have had projected numbers even better. What if ARod K'd the whole month he would have played. I don't go by what if's...I go by what was put up. What if ARod actually played well in the playoff's? Which he doesn't....see what I mean. Go by what he did, not what you think he would have done is all I'm saying.

[3arod13]

when it's all said and done....Giambi's gone