Schilling's famous bloody sock is turning into a bloody mess

[allstarsplus]

Mirabelli denies saying bloody sock wasn't real

ESPN.com news services


BALTIMORE -- The story of Curt Schilling's famous bloody sock from the 2004 playoffs is turning into a bloody mess after a prominent broadcaster claimed one of Schilling's teammates acknowledged the blood wasn't real.


Al Bello/Getty Images

Was it blood .. or something else? Curt Schilling's sock from Game 6 of the 2004 ALCS is once more the topic of conversation.

For those who have somehow forgotten, here's what happened: Schilling, who had a right ankle tendon injury, had sutures stitched into his ankle to keep the tendon stable so he could pitch in Game 6 against the New York Yankees in the 2004 American League Championship Series. A red stain, presumably blood, could be seen on the sock during the game, which the Red Sox won, and the sock was sent to the Baseball Hall of Fame in Cooperstown, N.Y., after the Red Sox won the 2004 World Series.

Fast-forward to Wednesday night's Mid-Atlantic Sports Network's telecast of Red Sox-Orioles.

In the bottom of the fifth, according to multiple media reports, Orioles play-by-play man Gary Thorne said on the air that he had been told by Red Sox catcher Doug Mirabelli that the substance was paint, not blood.

"The great story we were talking about the other night was that famous red stocking that he wore when they finally won, the blood on his stocking," Thorne told broadcast partner and Hall of Fame pitcher Jim Palmer, according to media reports.

"Nah," Thorne said. "It was painted. Doug Mirabelli confessed up to it after. It was all for PR. Two-ball, two-strike count."

Two innings later, according to media reports, Thorne explained Mirabelli had told him the story "a couple of years ago."

"Go ask him [Mirabelli]," Thorne said.

After the game, Mirabelli flatly and angrily denied Thorne's story.

"What? Are you kidding me? He's [expletive] lying. A straight lie," Mirabelli said, according to The Boston Globe. "I never said that. I know it was blood. Everybody knows it was blood."

"It gets stupider," Schilling added, according to the newspaper. "I got the 9-inch scar for you. You can see it. ... There are some bad people in your line of work, man."

Red Sox manager Terry Francona also questioned the story.
"What Schill did that night on the sports field was one of the most incredible feats I ever witnessed," Francona said, according to The Globe. "[Thorne's remarks] go so far past disappointing. Disrespectful to Schill, to his vocation. I'm stunned.

"I am just floored. Schill takes his share of shots, and this one is so far below the belt that I'm embarrassed and I wish somebody would have had the good conscience to ask me," Francona said, according to the newspaper.

[richpick]

Easy way to find out test the sock that was sent to Cooperstown. I think that if it was fake that Schilling is a PR genius and has gone up in my book!!!

[hblakewolf]

.....any chance Lampson can be contacted to make a quick run up north to Cooperstown? From what I remember, they also have some amazing bagel stores nearby!

Howard Wolf
hblakewolf@patmedia.net

[indyred]

Isn't there a bloody sock from Yanks series and another from his World Series game?

[staindsox]

Schilling said the one from the Yankees series was thrown away...unless a clubhouse kid grabbed it out of the garbage.

[TNTtoys]

I can picture the events unfolding... He's contacted by Hall of Fame museum to examine a sock... he's told that it should have blood on it... He hops into car with toolkit, roll of blank LOAs and 1 vile of blood...

[bubbrubb25]

I saw the sock at cooperstown at it dried like a maroon color just like dried blood would be.... it looked real to me

[gameused]

Heres a photo of Schilling's bloody sock!

[allstarsplus]

I had never seen the HOF pics before. The pattern of blood looks different between the 2 socks, and when I say the 2 socks I mean the one at the HOF and the one in the actual game pic. I would agree the HOF sock DEFINITELY looks like dried blood.

The sock from the picture of Schilling in the game has a line of blood under the stirrup and a different pattern. The HOF sock looks like dotted blood. Blood wouldn't evaporate and if anything would spread further through the cloth sock as it is absorbant like a paper towel.

I am starting to believe this alternate theory.

Andrew

[staindsox]

It's asinine to believe this stupid sh*t. Look at the photo. It's the same damn sock. Schilling's performance was the gutsiest thing I've ever seen in sports.