Results 1 to 10 of 44
-
10-02-2010, 07:19 PM #1
- Join Date
- Jul 2010
- Posts
- 33
Red and Blue Ball Mark
Can anybody tell me what the red and blue ball mark on this bat means? It's on the back barrel of the bat, but all the ball seam impressions are on the left barrel. The red and blue ball mark is on the bottom barrel and is larger than the blue ball marks on the left barrel where the ball seam impressions are. It appears to have been a glancing blow. Foul ball...........???? Or is this actually two different ball marks, one red and one blue? Thanks for your help.
-
10-02-2010, 10:26 PM #2
- Join Date
- Jul 2010
- Posts
- 33
Re: Red and Blue Ball Mark
PSA/DNA authenticated this bat, stating it's c. 2004. The PSA/DNA letter stated, "There is a red mark on the back barrel that appears to be a ball mark."
I paid $185.00 plus shipping to and from New Jersey for PSA/DNA services, so I felt they should have been decisive about this characteristic. Is it or isn't it a ball mark? To me, it obviously looks like the blue ball marks, except it's red. Why wasn't it obvious to PSA/DNA? Am I wrong, is it not a ball mark?
PSA/DNA also stated in the letter, "Also visible on the bat are red and blue bat rack streaks....." It does, but it also contains black bat rack streaks. The red and black streaks are much more predominant than the blue streaks. Why didn't the full authentication letter mention this obvious detail?
The PSA/DNA letter stated, "several ball marks and ball stitch impressions are visible on the left and back barrel. Ball marks include blue ink transfers." The back barrel doesn't contain ball stitch impressions. It contains a red and blue mark that "appears to be a ball mark." Or the marks are two different marks, one red and one blue.
When I received the bat and letter from PSA/DNA, I immediately thought it comparable to hiring someone to do construction work and receiving sloppy, incomplete results. No offense to anyone in construction; it's just what I thought at the time.
I've been submitting cards to PSA for years, so I decided to send this bat when I bought it from one of the members here. I believe it's been owned by three members here.
What would cause the red mark that appears to be a ball mark? Thanks for the help.
Greg Martin
-
10-02-2010, 10:35 PM #3
- Join Date
- Dec 2005
- Posts
- 338
Re: Red and Blue Ball Mark
Hello-
That is a great looking bat. The red marks are from the red stiches on the baseball. I have seen it on other bats and also from my experience with wood bats in baseball. It usually occurs with foul ball marks- speaks to the force with which it was hit.
Anyways, that is my take. Cheers! - Joe
-
10-02-2010, 10:37 PM #4
- Join Date
- Jun 2006
- Posts
- 3,533
Re: Red and Blue Ball Mark
My Travis Lee circa 2003 Devil Rays bat has a similar ball mark....actually has two of them.....
I believe there were special balls used after 9-11-01 and some of these balls have ended up in Batting Practice baseball bins......
-
10-02-2010, 11:26 PM #5
- Join Date
- Jul 2010
- Posts
- 33
Re: Red and Blue Ball Mark
Thanks guys. Good information and nice bat David!
I've already covered most everything in this paragraph, except for the cleat marks. PSA/DNA said cleat marks were visible on the back barrel. Hmm, they definitely didn't look at the bat for any length of time. Cleat marks are visible on each side.
The picture of the left barrel in my previous post showed the cleat marks there.
Here is the right barrel, which also demonstrates game use as this chunk likely wouldn't splinter in BP. Anybody have an opinion on how this occurred? My thought was that contact was attempted on the left barrel, as normal, but perhaps an off-speed pitch caused contact on the cup of the right barrel (?).:
Here's the front barrel:
-
10-03-2010, 12:23 AM #6
- Join Date
- Jul 2010
- Posts
- 33
Re: Red and Blue Ball Mark
Who saw it coming?
Evidence Pujols used this bat:- Pujols ordered the bat
- Pujols wrote his #5 on the cup
- Pujols wrote his #5 on the knob
- The #5 was not crossed out, etc by someone else on either end
- Deep seam trenches were embedded on the left barrel
- Seam impressions were on the sweet spot, high avg and power
- Blue ink transfers are present
- Red bat rack streaks are present
- Light coat of pine tar to handle
When a criminal investigator interviews a suspect, he or she will ask the suspect about the event in question, and the suspect will typically say, Well, I usually.........That's not what the investigator asked. He or she asked for specifics, not what is typical.
This picture was taken during the sixth inning of game 7, 2004 NLCS. I downloaded the game and watched some before work last week. Pujols was facing Clemens. Between each pitch, Pujols stepped out and grabbed the bat on the upper handle, intentionally applying pine tar to the lower handle. Coming through in the clutch, Pujols doubled:
This picture is from 9-17-04, Pujols 44th HR. Look at the pine tar on the handle and on his right glove:
-
10-03-2010, 09:57 AM #7
Re: Red and Blue Ball Mark
Greg,
First off, I love this bat. If you ever plan on selling it, let me know.
Secondly, I agree with your conclusion... given the photographic evidence, and I actually believe the photo where the ball is hitting him in the face is possibly a photomatch. I think at the very least the bat was used by Pujols and someone else.
Granted pine tar isn't a Pujols characteristic, however, you have provided photos that show that it has happened. As for the stitch marks, the conclusion from other members is correct.
Great bat.
-Tony[SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
Always looking for ALEX AVILA, ALBERT PUJOLS, HOME RUN BATS, and any high end gamers from 90's-00's stars.
Tony Servitto
My Email: servitto84@yahoo.com
My Website: http://vitosbatsandmemorabilia.webs.com/
-
10-03-2010, 10:02 AM #8
- Join Date
- Oct 2009
- Posts
- 478
-
10-03-2010, 10:10 AM #9
Re: Red and Blue Ball Mark
Its not going to be definitive, but the 5 looks the same... I wouldn't chalk it up, but I believe the bat is genuine. Take it easy on me, geez.
Tough crowd.
-Tony[SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
Always looking for ALEX AVILA, ALBERT PUJOLS, HOME RUN BATS, and any high end gamers from 90's-00's stars.
Tony Servitto
My Email: servitto84@yahoo.com
My Website: http://vitosbatsandmemorabilia.webs.com/
-
10-03-2010, 10:10 AM #10
- Join Date
- Oct 2009
- Posts
- 478