Quote Originally Posted by ironmanfan View Post
I personally would use PSA over SGC (my Ripken/Charlotte card is in a PSA holder)...Do you live anywhere near a show where PSA may be set up? That way you could talk to a rep and sub it in person....On a "raw" card, I'd use a declared value of $2500
I would still say $4500, unless the card looks damaged (dented corners, creased, etc). It doesn't cost you any more (fee & return postage are same for $2500 or $4500), and if it's lost or damaged while with PSA, you'll get a higher settlement.