Reds/Padres trade--Good, bad or ???

[jbsportstuff]

As a Reds fan, I think that the Reds literally gave up the farm. These trading chips should never have been packaged like this. We all realized that Alonso and Grandal were trading chips, but NEVER in the same package. If we end up getting a STRONG #1 then fine. Only time will tell...I'm not bettting on a strong return for my Reds. I HOPE I get to eat my words.

[vdsporty25]

Looking at the landscape of the game today I absolutely love this deal for the Red Legs!! Giving up Grandal and Alonso in the same deal was painful however giving up Volquez was a blessing as most fans were growing tired of his inconsistent effort and work ethic. Boxberger was the wildcard in this deal. If he becomes a solid starter it hurts a little more than if he is a above average reliever which I think you can find elsewhere. What the Reds picked up was a potential ace type pitcher with 4 seasons of team control. His stuff is filthy and with the money being handed to guys like CJ Wilson on the FA market this is the only way for a team like the Reds to acquire big time arms while trying to make a run in the NL. If they can add another RH hitter to add in the middle of the lineup and a closer I believe they have a great chance to do some damage this year and beyond. GO REDS!!!!!!!!!