Why you can't trust baseball cards for photo matching

[r_phelps]

Re: Why you can't trust baseball cards for photo matching

Is it me or does the Butler bat say Garrett Jones Twins?

[CampWest]

Re: Why you can't trust baseball cards for photo matching

I've also seen Topps and Upper Deck both add a bat barrel to a picture where a player is holding just the handle after a total break of the bat.

Here is the UD card with added Louisville bat barrel. And the same at bat from Getty... and another showing he was using his normal Phoenix, not a Louisville.

[2020mike]

Re: Why you can't trust baseball cards for photo matching

I miss the good old card days when a guy was traded you'd get his card and it would simply state "TRADED" and have the new teams logo somewhere even if he was wearing his former teams uniform.

[ironmanfan]

Re: Why you can't trust baseball cards for photo matching

here is a situation where Topps made a base umpire disappear

[CampWest]

Re: Why you can't trust baseball cards for photo matching

I've also seen Topps and Upper Deck both add a bat barrel to a picture where a player is holding just the handle after a total break of the bat.

[Dach0sen0ne]

Re: Why you can't trust baseball cards for photo matching

This is a photoshop job. This is a Yankee uniform and they converted the helmet into a Tigers helmet.

[ironmanfan]

Re: Why you can't trust baseball cards for photo matching

Sometimes it's not even be the right player. This is Austin Jackson, but Topps says its Francisco Cervelli. LOL

The hell with Jackson, I'm wondering who the chick in the front row drinking a beer is..............

[Dach0sen0ne]

Re: Why you can't trust baseball cards for photo matching

Sometimes it's not even be the right player. This is Austin Jackson, but Topps says its Francisco Cervelli. LOL

[ironmanfan]

Re: Why you can't trust baseball cards for photo matching

I think last year Topps photo shopped Roy Halladay wearing a Phillies uniform bearing #32 (Steve Carlton's retired #).

I would hope that any savy collector would realize this was a photo shop, but I suppose you never know.

[LastingsMilledge85]

Re: Why you can't trust baseball cards for photo matching

A lot of baseball card companies, most notably Topps, takes road pictures (because it is easier and more practical than home pictures) of players to use on their cards when they join a new team for the following season, from there they edit the players to have their new teams uniforms. It is very easy to point out when they do this, they also do it with football.

[Birdbats]

For the record, Berkman is wearing #12 this season. The #17 is retired in honor of Dizzy Dean. The Cardinals also don't have a pinstripe running down their pant legs. At least in the old days the "artistry" was obvious.