e-bay deal question

[ndevlin]

Re: e-bay deal question

You put "John Doe game used bat" in the title and the description? Guaranteed it to be authentic, I send it in to get authenticated and I cant. Is that right?

Im not saying you are wrong, but if I bought a bat that was guaranteed authentic, and I then sent it in for authentication, and they wont do it for whatever reason, Id be a little upset too.

[justinlm24]

Re: e-bay deal question

only thing I said in the auction was.."I bought this bat from a reputable dealer, and is guranteed authentic." Nothing about guaranteeing it to pass any authentication process. No he never left me any feedback, just got an e-mail that he recieved the bat and that it looked good. That in my mind tells me he certified that the bat was as described in the listing. Only way I'll issue a refund is if paypal makes me. We shall see.......

[Lokee]

Re: e-bay deal question

he has 45 days to make a claim through paypal. Did he leave you a positive ? If he did your chances would be better winning the paypal case. If not 99.9% of the time paypal will grant the buyer a refund pending his return of the item to you.

[eisenreich8]

Re: e-bay deal question

If you would post the eBay auction number here there are those of us who would like to assist you, I am sure.

[Jags Fan Dan]

Re: e-bay deal question

Did you guarantee the bat to pass authentication? It sounds like the fact that Taube won't authenticate it doesn't mean it is not authentic. I say you do not owe a refund unless you made an explicit guarantee that it would pass PSA/DNA cert.

[justinlm24]

I don't know what the deal is with people these days, but it never ceases to amaze me. Ok I sold a bat on e-bay nearly a month ago. Buyer paid with paypal, and bat was sent out. He got it and said everything looked good. I recieved an e-mail from him several days ago saying he sent the bat out for authentication to psa/dna and they would not authenticate it. Now he is wanting a refund. I exchanged e-mails with john taube and he said the bat was authentic, and may very well have been used by the player, but he couldn't attribute all the use to the player. Therefore he wasn't going to authenticate it. The buyer claims to have spoken with paypal and they told him he was owed a refund. However I called and spoke with someone at paypal and they told me I am not obligated to issue a refund. The buyer is trying to claim the item was not as described, when in fact it was. Taube never said the bat was never used by the player. Whats the right thing to do in this case?