George Brett's last home game bat... NOT!

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • CampWest
    Senior Member
    • May 2008
    • 1507

    George Brett's last home game bat... NOT!

    What the heck??? Is Borat selling great game used items now.

    Beware of ebay seller rjbmagic1974. He intentionally misleads and misrepresents his items. If he has so little integrity, how are we to trust his items are genuine?

    He feels the need to intentionally lie and mislead on what appears to be an incredible George Brett gamer.




    Auction title:
    George Brett last home game used bat

    Auction description:
    This Louisville Slugger model C271 bat was used by George Brett in his last home game. The bat show a great deal of use and the pine tar is caked heavily. No it's not THAT BAT but is is a great piece used by a great hitter and hall of famer. It comes with very nice wall mont display case.

    ++++++++++++++
    Thats right, "this is the bat...no its not that bat"

    Ugh, intentionally misleading potential buyers? WHY??? Why in the world does rjbmagic1974 think intentionally misrepresenting $4500 items is a good way to earn a potential buyer's trust. Its a phenomenal looking bat, but if he feels the need to lie, why would I fork over $4500 to him?

    sigpic
    Wes Campbell
  • sctizzle
    Senior Member
    • Nov 2005
    • 419

    #2
    Re: George Brett's last home game bat... NOT!

    I read it as him saying it's not the pine tar incident bat...

    Comment

    • kylehess10
      Senior Member
      • Feb 2006
      • 3100

      #3
      Re: George Brett's last home game bat... NOT!

      Originally posted by sctizzle
      I read it as him saying it's not the pine tar incident bat...

      That's what I think too when I read it
      kylehess941@hotmail.com

      My Game Used Collection:
      http://www.wix.com/kylehess941/gameused


      http://www.kylehessphotography.com/

      Comment

      • CampWest
        Senior Member
        • May 2008
        • 1507

        #4
        Re: George Brett's last home game bat... NOT!

        Thats an interesting take I would not have come to on my own. I'm not disagreeing with you, but why do you read that into it, when he makes no mention or allusion to the pine tar incident?

        Pine Tar Incident seems like an odd event to refer to when discussing his last home game since that was 10 years earlier.

        I guess I should temper my confusion and frustration over the listing. I guess it is possible he's alluding to an event that was 10 years earlier and was an obviously totally different labeling period with totally different tar application. Maybe he does maintain its the last home game bat. Perhaps the akward statement is confusing but not an admission of intentional misleading as I originally assumed, in my not reading the unwritten.

        It is the right label period to potentially be from his last season. I withdraw my harsh criticism pending further information.

        Originally posted by sctizzle
        I read it as him saying it's not the pine tar incident bat...
        sigpic
        Wes Campbell

        Comment

        • MichaelofSF
          Senior Member
          • Apr 2007
          • 503

          #5
          Re: George Brett's last home game bat... NOT!

          the George Brett last home game jersey that he is selling is incorrect. In 1993 the Royals had a full block #5, note the 5 style on the jersey being sold. There is an extra bend on the 5 that is being offered.

          Comment

          • sctizzle
            Senior Member
            • Nov 2005
            • 419

            #6
            Re: George Brett's last home game bat... NOT!

            I agree he worded it very weird, but I took it as him saying it was not the pine tar game bat because it came right after him saying it was caked in pine tar.

            Comment

            • 3arod13
              Senior Member
              • Apr 2006
              • 3093

              #7
              Re: George Brett's last home game bat... NOT!

              It sure does look like an awesome heavy game used bat though.
              Regards, Tony

              sigpic

              ~I'm sorry, I can't hear you....my World Series Ring is making too much NOISE! - Alex Rodriguez~

              Comment

              • CampWest
                Senior Member
                • May 2008
                • 1507

                #8
                Re: George Brett's last home game bat... NOT!

                Originally posted by MichaelofSF
                the George Brett last home game jersey that he is selling is incorrect. In 1993 the Royals had a full block #5, note the 5 style on the jersey being sold. There is an extra bend on the 5 that is being offered.
                Interesting... I have not any expertise in jerseys, though I was at the last home game and took pictures, so if I can find those I'll let you know what I see. Does it appear that there is a weird stain around the date signed on the jersey? It appears to me that its a discoloration of some sort, perhaps a yellowish tint.




                I think you are right on the 5.. the corner on the left before the bottom half circle of the 5 should be a right angle. The below is not the last home game but is 1993. Hold on... let me find my pictures from that game and scan one in.

                sigpic
                Wes Campbell

                Comment

                • CampWest
                  Senior Member
                  • May 2008
                  • 1507

                  #9
                  Re: George Brett's last home game JERSEY... NOT!

                  Michael... as usual you are dead on correct...
                  Here is the purported jersey:




                  Here is a few pictures I took from the front row at that game.. Note the extra bend in the for sale jersey versus this picture. (wish I had a better telephoto lens back then... these are pretty seriously cropped - but good enough to prove the point)







                  Originally posted by MichaelofSF
                  the George Brett last home game jersey that he is selling is incorrect. In 1993 the Royals had a full block #5, note the 5 style on the jersey being sold. There is an extra bend on the 5 that is being offered.
                  sigpic
                  Wes Campbell

                  Comment

                  • bigtruck260
                    Senior Member
                    • Sep 2007
                    • 1729

                    #10
                    Re: George Brett's last home game bat... NOT!

                    Originally posted by CampWest
                    Interesting... I have not any expertise in jerseys, though I was at the last home game and took pictures, so if I can find those I'll let you know what I see. Does it appear that there is a weird stain around the date signed on the jersey? It appears to me that its a discoloration of some sort, perhaps a yellowish tint.
                    That discoloration is mighty suspicious.
                    Dave
                    Looking for 1990's STL Cardinal starting pitcher's bats
                    River City Redbird Authentics
                    http://www.freewebs.com/bigtruck260/

                    sigpic

                    Comment

                    • kingjammy24
                      Senior Member
                      • Nov 2005
                      • 3119

                      #11
                      Re: George Brett's last home game bat... NOT!

                      the front "5" and back "5" are not correct for either 1993 or even 1992.

                      jersey has a collar tag which is atypical. strangely, it's not the first brett jersey i've seen with a collar tag.

                      anyway, the tagging is odd. i'm not sure how spares were tagged for the royals in 1993 but it would seem strange to tag them with a set number (in this case, set 3). i'd think the spares either wouldn't be strip tagged at all or tagged with only the year. here's a comparison of the ebay brett tagging with other 1993 royals tagging. it's almost as if someone took a standard royals tag and cut the portion that had the player number and name off and were left with just the bottom set-year portion.



                      rudy.

                      Comment

                      • CampWest
                        Senior Member
                        • May 2008
                        • 1507

                        #12
                        Re: George Brett's last home game bat... NOT!

                        Nice work Rudy/kingjammy. Thanks

                        Originally posted by kingjammy24
                        the front "5" and back "5" are not correct for either 1993 or even 1992.

                        jersey has a collar tag which is atypical. strangely, it's not the first brett jersey i've seen with a collar tag.

                        anyway, the tagging is odd. i'm not sure how spares were tagged for the royals in 1993 but it would seem strange to tag them with a set number (in this case, set 3). i'd think the spares either wouldn't be strip tagged at all or tagged with only the year. here's a comparison of the ebay brett tagging with other 1993 royals tagging. it's almost as if someone took a standard royals tag and cut the portion that had the player number and name off and were left with just the bottom set-year portion.

                        rudy.
                        sigpic
                        Wes Campbell

                        Comment

                        • suicide_squeeze
                          Senior Member
                          • Dec 2008
                          • 1442

                          #13
                          Re: George Brett's last home game bat... NOT!

                          In regards to his "last game used bat", I asked the seller the following:

                          Dear rjbmagic1974,

                          Hello, very nice bat. I was wondering, how do you know it was used in his last home game? Does it come with a letter from him stating so? I am very interested in this bat, thanks.

                          - suicide_squeeze




                          Here was his responce:


                          Dear suicide_squeeze,

                          The same person who was close to Brett got the bat and jersey immediately after the game. I got them shortly afterwards and have had them since. George gave away lots of things to people he liked including several awards that he won throughout his career which I have seen in auctions. This is a really great piece. Whoever buys it will not be disappointed.

                          - rjbmagic1974




                          They'll be disappointed if they are buying it thinking it was used in Brett's last game.....








                          Comment

                          • CampWest
                            Senior Member
                            • May 2008
                            • 1507

                            #14
                            Re: George Brett's last home game bat... NOT!

                            Question:

                            Dear rjbmagic1974,
                            How were you able to acquire both Brett's last home game jersey and last home game bat? Trying to establish the provenance before considering any bids. Thanks.

                            Response:
                            Although they weren't given directly to me that night, they were given to a person I knew and then indirectly to me. If you have ever seen any of the books that cam out about Brett shortly after retirement, you will see him wearing the jersey and using the bat. I am a private collector who doesn't buy and sell for a living. I would not have anything in my collection that was phoney. I am only selling because I have a chance to buy some very expensive items that I have been eyeing for years.
                            - rjbmagic1974


                            Originally posted by suicide_squeeze
                            In regards to his "last game used bat", I asked the seller the following:
                            sigpic
                            Wes Campbell

                            Comment

                            • spartakid
                              Senior Member
                              • Oct 2008
                              • 1281

                              #15
                              Re: George Brett's last home game bat... NOT!

                              Has anyone pointed out the proof you guys have come us with? Would be interesting to see what he says....
                              Ricardo Montoya

                              ri.montoya at yahoo dot com

                              Comment

                              Working...