Correct an Error! Chipper Jones black Mizuno gamers

[shoremen44]

Re: Correct an Error! Chipper Jones black Mizuno gamers

LOL. Me too!

Maybe we could start a Game Used research company. We could call it Bert & Scott Research, or BS Research for short.

HMMMM... BS... yes there would be alot of that...lol

[5kRunner]

Re: Correct an Error! Chipper Jones black Mizuno gamers

Vonbrandingo,
I guess the ball marks could have been made in BP. But I always thought BP use = Game use as far as MLB was concerned. May not be the same for PSA/DNA.

Hope everything works out for you. Good luck!

[vonbrandingo]

Re: Correct an Error! Chipper Jones black Mizuno gamers

Vonbrandingo,
I guess the ball marks could have been made in BP. But I always thought BP use = Game use as far as MLB was concerned. May not be the same for PSA/DNA.

Hope everything works out for you. Good luck!

Thanks! I've noticed that PSA/DNA distinguishes between BP used and game used bats and BP bats grade much lower, something like a GU 5 at the most.

Thanks again for your help Scott. I'll post Mr. Taube's findings when I get them. In the meantime, I'll see if I can find some evidence of him using 34" bats during 2003-06.

[redoctober]

Re: Correct an Error! Chipper Jones black Mizuno gamers

Not at all glad that you got a poor grade here -- I hope the "appeal" comes back positive for you.

However, I am glad to see that JT is offering honest opinions with his grades. It is clear that his opinions can be respected and this is just one more example.

While it may appear that a "mistake" was made here, I would argue that this is the type of info that we should expect from a reputable authenticator. And it is clear that the "mistake" would be on the manufacturer's end, not JT's.

[vonbrandingo]

Re: Correct an Error! Chipper Jones black Mizuno gamers

Not at all glad that you got a poor grade here -- I hope the "appeal" comes back positive for you.

However, I am glad to see that JT is offering honest opinions with his grades. It is clear that his opinions can be respected and this is just one more example.

While it may appear that a "mistake" was made here, I would argue that this is the type of info that we should expect from a reputable authenticator. And it is clear that the "mistake" would be on the manufacturer's end, not JT's.

This reminds me of the Chris Rock bit about lowered expectations. Right, it is clear that JT tried to do his homework before authenticating and grading this bat. That's what I'd hope to get for my $150 and that's what anyone would hope for because that's why people buy PSA/DNA authenticated bats at a premium.

Has JT never authenticated a Chipper Jones black Mizuno or even a blonde one? The fact that the statement that he has never used a Mizuno in games was printed on the LOA makes me seriously question some things. This is just another example of how even reputable authenticators' opinions are subject to questioning, even if opinions are honest.

[Capital-Sports]

Re: Correct an Error! Chipper Jones black Mizuno gamers

The only thing that sucks about black Chipper Jones Mizuno bats is that ASI and Historic Auctions have been selling these for years.......un used....

[5kRunner]

Re: Correct an Error! Chipper Jones black Mizuno gamers

Not at all glad that you got a poor grade here -- I hope the "appeal" comes back positive for you.

However, I am glad to see that JT is offering honest opinions with his grades. It is clear that his opinions can be respected and this is just one more example.

While it may appear that a "mistake" was made here, I would argue that this is the type of info that we should expect from a reputable authenticator. And it is clear that the "mistake" would be on the manufacturer's end, not JT's.

I'm by no means questioning John's opinion on this bat. I've never talked with him, and he's probably forgot more about bats than I will ever know. But there are two statements on that LOA that are confusing/incorrect. The statement from Mizuno stating Jones has never used their bats in a game, and the statement about Jones only using a black bat from the right side of the plate. He may be referring only to the labeling period of this bat, and that might be right. But as it is stated, I think its confusing. And if he isn't referring to the labeling period of this bat, those statements are incorrect.

[joelsabi]

Re: Correct an Error! Chipper Jones black Mizuno gamers

labeling period says 2003 to 2006 on the LOA. So Taube probably was looking at images from that period.

they photos you guys provide was from April 1998 and some of the cards were late 1990s


maybe thats why. let us know what Taube finds.

[joelsabi]

Re: Correct an Error! Chipper Jones black Mizuno gamers

Getty Editorial Image #307978 & #307985

Looks like a Mizuno to me.

this is from April 1998

[redoctober]

Re: Correct an Error! Chipper Jones black Mizuno gamers

This reminds me of the Chris Rock bit about lowered expectations. Right, it is clear that JT tried to do his homework before authenticating and grading this bat. That's what I'd hope to get for my $150 and that's what anyone would hope for because that's why people buy PSA/DNA authenticated bats at a premium.

Has JT never authenticated a Chipper Jones black Mizuno or even a blonde one? The fact that the statement that he has never used a Mizuno in games was printed on the LOA makes me seriously question some things. This is just another example of how even reputable authenticators' opinions are subject to questioning, even if opinions are honest.

I can't agree more -- authenticators are simply providing an opinion. I would be very interested to see if JT has EVER authenticated a Mizuno Chipper bat higher than GU5. If so, then, absolutely, this opinion would come into serious question.

From my collecting/observations, authentic black GU'd Chipper bats are always Glomar or Rawlings. I have never seen Minuno's in this decade.

Anyone have a GU 6 or better from JT????


JT -- your thoughts???

[suicide_squeeze]

Re: Correct an Error! Chipper Jones black Mizuno gamers

Just got home and read this thread for the first time....

Here's my 2 cents as a LONGtime Chipper fan....and I am not posting this info to burst anyone's bubble....I just know a lot about Chipper as I have always felt he would one day make it to the 500 home-run club. Therefore, he has always been closely followed by me. (And as a side note, I believe he has always played the game clean.....NO PED's IMHO).



I'm not so sure Taube is wrong.....but it's the old "symantics" game.

If you refer to a "pre-season" game as a game where a bat used in it makes the bat a "gamer"....then it's a boo-boo based on your definition.

I am from the school that if the at bat is in a game that doesn't count towards the players career total......it ain't squat. It's not a true "gamer". It "doesn't count"......doesn't matter......has very little significance.

That said, I know from following Chipper's career, that he has been a LONG TIME (career-long) Rawlings guy, has used "black Glomar" bats for a few years, and on occasion in his early career (and perhaps on a few trial basis times here and there) played around with L.S.'s (BMH can probably qualify to what extent).

But I do know this: John Taube, when referring to a Black Mizuno as "not used in a game".......he is referring to the fact Chipper does not use them in a regular season game. He used them in pre-season, and most likely in batting practice (as is the case for a lot of major leaguers......to change up between B.P. and "gamers" in what brand or stlye bat they use).

He also has strickly used black bats while hitting from the right side of the plate, while regigated to blonde bats from the left.......his whole career.

Are there exceptions? Of course there are, and we can all speculate as to the reasons why....but they would not be important. Chipper uses as a rule blonde bats as a lefty, and black as a righty.....as a rule.

[vonbrandingo]

Re: Correct an Error! Chipper Jones black Mizuno gamers

Just got home and read this thread for the first time....

Here's my 2 cents as a LONGtime Chipper fan....and I am not posting this info to burst anyone's bubble....I just know a lot about Chipper as I have always felt he would one day make it to the 500 home-run club. Therefore, he has always been closely followed by me. (And as a side note, I believe he has always played the game clean.....NO PED's IMHO).



I'm not so sure Taube is wrong.....but it's the old "symantics" game.

If you refer to a "pre-season" game as a game where a bat used in it makes the bat a "gamer"....then it's a boo-boo based on your definition.

I am from the school that if the at bat is in a game that doesn't count towards the players career total......it ain't squat. It's not a true "gamer". It "doesn't count"......doesn't matter......has very little significance.

That said, I know from following Chipper's career, that he has been a LONG TIME (career-long) Rawlings guy, has used "black Glomar" bats for a few years, and on occasion in his early career (and perhaps on a few trial basis times here and there) played around with L.S.'s (BMH can probably qualify to what extent).

But I do know this: John Taube, when referring to a Black Mizuno as "not used in a game".......he is referring to the fact Chipper does not use them in a regular season game. He used them in pre-season, and most likely in batting practice (as is the case for a lot of major leaguers......to change up between B.P. and "gamers" in what brand or stlye bat they use).

He also has strickly used black bats while hitting from the right side of the plate, while regigated to blonde bats from the left.......his whole career.

Are there exceptions? Of course there are, and we can all speculate as to the reasons why....but they would not be important. Chipper uses as a rule blonde bats as a lefty, and black as a righty.....as a rule.

You're not bursting my bubble, in fact I think you're outside the bubble with your 2 cents.

[vonbrandingo]

Re: Correct an Error! Chipper Jones black Mizuno gamers

This bat is 34" long and Mizuno confirmed that 34" bats like this one were sent to Chipper to try during 2003-06. Now the real question with this bat is whether Chipper used the 34" bats as gamers since he used 35" bats during this period. Any evidence (photo, print, etc.) proving yes or no would be greatly appreciated.

[Capital-Sports]

Re: Correct an Error! Chipper Jones black Mizuno gamers

Call ASI, they probably have 1000's of these bats left.