James Spence's "Lifetime Guarantee"

[3arod13]

Re: James Spence's "Lifetime Guarantee"

UPDATE:
James Spence has reached out to me and offered to discuss the matter when he returns to his office on Friday. He says it will give us the chance to "resolve this matter properly."

Hopefully he will do the right thing...

Let's hope so! His name is on it! His own people (company) say it's no good! This is a no-brainer! I would give you your money back and then some! Good luck Eric!

[Roady]

Re: James Spence's "Lifetime Guarantee"

I have a question.....I understand you have a LOA for the ball.

How does one know the LOA goes with your ball? Does the ball and LOA have a matching hologram # or is there anything else that proves the LOA and the ball go together?

Just playing devils advocate and trying to learn.
Thanks

[Roady]

Re: James Spence's "Lifetime Guarantee"

And I am talking about he original hand written LOA that you have.
Thanks

[mbrieve]

Re: James Spence's "Lifetime Guarantee"

Eric, do you still think the ball is "good" or do you think they got it "right" this time and Spence was wrong/inexperienced 20 years ago?

What I'm getting at is there are a lot of self-proclaimed experts and even I can get mesmerized by the JSA or PSA stickers. However, I have seen plenty of examples where a signature is an autopen or just a scribble that I would have a really hard time believing is able to be authenticated (i.e. modern day Al Pacino or Brian Wilson (Beach Boy), where it is essentially a check mark or indiscernible chicken scratch) with the JSA or PSA stamp of approval.

Regardless, I do think a lifetime guarantee should mean something and he should be a man of his word. I don't know if that means a refund at your purchase price or what the original buyer paid for it. Bottom line, is this is a mess.

Good job using social media to shed some light on the situation!

[rufusandherschel]

Re: James Spence's "Lifetime Guarantee"

This is a no-brainer!

+1

[tiger7171]

Re: James Spence's "Lifetime Guarantee"

posted story on friends facebook page and he got irate with me since JSA is coming to his store on sunday.

[3arod13]

Re: James Spence's "Lifetime Guarantee"

posted story on friends facebook page and he got irate with me since JSA is coming to his store on sunday.

I believe that these days, everything is about the "All Mighty $$$." People will turn their head to almost everything and anything, if it will put money in their pocket.

Not directing this specifically at your friend.

[flaco1801]

Re: James Spence's "Lifetime Guarantee"

I dont understand taking all this BAD publicity for a 200 item....These people are hustlers not business people....I am glad i NEVER bid on any of these "auctions" they are ALL scams...

[CollectGU]

Re: James Spence's "Lifetime Guarantee"

I dont understand taking all this BAD publicity for a 200 item....These people are hustlers not business people....I am glad i NEVER bid on any of these "auctions" they are ALL scams...

Slightly off topic, but if you can find me Casey Stengel single signed balls for $200, I'd break my wrist reaching into my pocket to buy them....

[Phil316]

Re: James Spence's "Lifetime Guarantee"

Slightly off topic, but if you can find me Casey Stengel single signed balls for $200, I'd break my wrist reaching into my pocket to buy them....

And no Coaches Corner links lol

[ironmanfan]

Re: James Spence's "Lifetime Guarantee"

I know the heat is on Spence (understandably) but I also think Millwich has some accountability in this as well.

[danesei@yahoo.com]

Re: James Spence's "Lifetime Guarantee"

UPDATE:
James Spence has reached out to me and offered to discuss the matter when he returns to his office on Friday. He says it will give us the chance to "resolve this matter properly."

Hopefully he will do the right thing...

You should ask for $200+3.5% annual interest, compounded continuously.

[mbrieve]

Re: James Spence's "Lifetime Guarantee"

Where is everyone getting $200 from? I think it sold for $1,500???

[danesei@yahoo.com]

Re: James Spence's "Lifetime Guarantee"

Where is everyone getting $200 from? I think it sold for $1,500???

Then $1500 at 3.5% annual... $3020.63.

In any case, I think that the guy who sold the ball to Eric should be held responsible to Eric, and then Spence held liable to the second party. That makes the most sense to me.

[3arod13]

Re: James Spence's "Lifetime Guarantee"

In any case, I think that the guy who sold the ball to Eric should be held responsible to Eric, and then Spence held liable to the second party. That makes the most sense to me.

Interesting. I think Spence should be responsible to Eric and end it there. Each time that ball changed hands, it had a lot to do with the LOA attached to the ball for each buyer. To hold buyers accountable, when they did nothing wrong, is difficult for me to take. However, that's just my opinion.