Anybody Have Guilts About Game-Used Collecting

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • godwulf
    Senior Member
    • Aug 2007
    • 1864

    #61
    Re: Anybody Have Guilts About Game-Used Collecting

    So far, most of the guilt feelings discussed have related to money - whether you could be doing something "more worthwhile", whether for yourself or someone else, with the bucks you spend on the hobby...but another "guilt feelings" aspect just occurred to me.

    A number of years ago, I bought an old game-used Dwayne Murphy gamer from a guy in the media who knew all the DBacks bat boys at the time, and was always getting bats from them to put on eBay or sell directly to me; Murphy was a DBacks coach at the time. The bat was obviously from Murphy's playing days, and I was told that the bat boy had "asked him for one of his old bats", and Murphy had brought this bat from home, presumably from his own collection, and given it to the bat boy...who immediately sold it to me for fifty bucks.

    Now, I suspect that Murphy would not have been quite so eager to give away one of his old gamers to the kid, if he'd known that the kid was just going to turn around and sell it - is that fair to say? So, even though I don't think that I necessarily did anything wrong in the situation...I still felt somewhat funny about it, and still do. It's not like I recruited the bat boy to get one of Murphy's bats, or anything like that; still, I have to admit to feeling a little guilty about the bat coming to me the way it did. Do you know what I mean?
    Jeff
    godwulf1@cox.net

    Comment

    • Vintagedeputy
      Senior Member
      • Oct 2005
      • 3172

      #62
      Re: Anybody Have Guilts About Game-Used Collecting

      Originally posted by godwulf
      So far, most of the guilt feelings discussed have related to money - whether you could be doing something "more worthwhile", whether for yourself or someone else, with the bucks you spend on the hobby...but another "guilt feelings" aspect just occurred to me.

      A number of years ago, I bought an old game-used Dwayne Murphy gamer from a guy in the media who knew all the DBacks bat boys at the time, and was always getting bats from them to put on eBay or sell directly to me; Murphy was a DBacks coach at the time. The bat was obviously from Murphy's playing days, and I was told that the bat boy had "asked him for one of his old bats", and Murphy had brought this bat from home, presumably from his own collection, and given it to the bat boy...who immediately sold it to me for fifty bucks.

      Now, I suspect that Murphy would not have been quite so eager to give away one of his old gamers to the kid, if he'd known that the kid was just going to turn around and sell it - is that fair to say? So, even though I don't think that I necessarily did anything wrong in the situation...I still felt somewhat funny about it, and still do. It's not like I recruited the bat boy to get one of Murphy's bats, or anything like that; still, I have to admit to feeling a little guilty about the bat coming to me the way it did. Do you know what I mean?
      I understand what you are saying, and I dont think that in that case you should feel guilty.

      I have a gorgeous Mark Grace gamer from his last season as a D-Back. He gave bat to former pitcher/teammate Scott Service as a momento of his career. Service ended up giving the bat to a police officer and the officer put it up on ebay where I bought it.

      I'm sure that Gracie didnt intend for the bat to take that route, but it did through no fault of his and I bought it through no fault of mine. No guilt, no worries. Grace was always a favorite of mine and its a treasured piece of my collection.

      Comment

      • chakes89
        Senior Member
        • May 2006
        • 1706

        #63
        Re: Anybody Have Guilts About Game-Used Collecting

        I regret paying $95 for a Felipe Lopez bat back in 2002
        I collect Jay Bruce and Cincinnati Reds Minor League stuff


        My email address: hakes89@gmail.com

        Comment

        • godwulf
          Senior Member
          • Aug 2007
          • 1864

          #64
          Re: Anybody Have Guilts About Game-Used Collecting

          Originally posted by chakes89
          I regret paying $95 for a Felipe Lopez bat back in 2002
          Why is that?
          Jeff
          godwulf1@cox.net

          Comment

          • suicide_squeeze
            Senior Member
            • Dec 2008
            • 1442

            #65
            Re: Anybody Have Guilts About Game-Used Collecting

            Originally posted by godwulf
            So far, most of the guilt feelings discussed have related to money - whether you could be doing something "more worthwhile", whether for yourself or someone else, with the bucks you spend on the hobby...but another "guilt feelings" aspect just occurred to me.

            A number of years ago, I bought an old game-used Dwayne Murphy gamer from a guy in the media who knew all the DBacks bat boys at the time, and was always getting bats from them to put on eBay or sell directly to me; Murphy was a DBacks coach at the time. The bat was obviously from Murphy's playing days, and I was told that the bat boy had "asked him for one of his old bats", and Murphy had brought this bat from home, presumably from his own collection, and given it to the bat boy...who immediately sold it to me for fifty bucks.

            Now, I suspect that Murphy would not have been quite so eager to give away one of his old gamers to the kid, if he'd known that the kid was just going to turn around and sell it - is that fair to say? So, even though I don't think that I necessarily did anything wrong in the situation...I still felt somewhat funny about it, and still do. It's not like I recruited the bat boy to get one of Murphy's bats, or anything like that; still, I have to admit to feeling a little guilty about the bat coming to me the way it did. Do you know what I mean?
            I know EXACTLY what you're talking about, godwulf.



            I'll give you $60.00 bucks for it!???

            Comment

            • godwulf
              Senior Member
              • Aug 2007
              • 1864

              #66
              Re: Anybody Have Guilts About Game-Used Collecting

              Originally posted by suicide_squeeze
              I know EXACTLY what you're talking about, godwulf.

              I'll give you $60.00 bucks for it!???
              Nah...it's the only Murphy bat I own, and I try to get at least one for every coach who comes through the organization. I even managed to find one of Buck Showalter's, from back in his minor league playing days.
              Jeff
              godwulf1@cox.net

              Comment

              • chakes89
                Senior Member
                • May 2006
                • 1706

                #67
                Re: Anybody Have Guilts About Game-Used Collecting

                Originally posted by godwulf
                Why is that?
                Because he never panned out like he was supposed to with the Reds and I only got $25 when I sold it
                I collect Jay Bruce and Cincinnati Reds Minor League stuff


                My email address: hakes89@gmail.com

                Comment

                • both-teams-played-hard
                  Senior Member
                  • Nov 2005
                  • 2712

                  #68
                  Re: Anybody Have Guilts About Game-Used Collecting

                  I feel guilty because of a purchase I made on the "Shop at Home" channel a few years ago. I bought a 1987 Bellingham Mariners team set for $199. It's worth at least five thousand dollars. I consider it an investment. If those folks were foolish enough to sell it at such a bargain...then, that's their own fault. By the way, it's factory sealed. Yes, I said factory sealed! PRISTINE condition! This mp3 link is from that magical night:
                  billingham.mp3
                  This is one of the greatest deals ever offered on "Shop at Home". Factory sealed!

                  Comment

                  • JasonBanz
                    Senior Member
                    • Oct 2008
                    • 592

                    #69
                    Re: Anybody Have Guilts About Game-Used Collecting

                    Guilt? As long as I can afford it and the wife is happy and has enough money for her scrapbooking stuff, no guilt!

                    Comment

                    Working...