Dawson In As An Expo!!!!!!!

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • jobathenut
    Senior Member
    • Nov 2008
    • 1085

    #16
    Re: Dawson In As An Expo!!!!!!!

    This goes great with a thread i started awhile ago.Asking if the hall or the player decided what team.And who has the power,can the hall say no you are going in as this team.Even if the player does not want to.And i just read on fox sports that he wanted to go in as a cub and the hall said no you have to go in as a expo.So i guess that ansewers my question.

    Comment

    • legaleagle92481
      Banned
      • Oct 2009
      • 2538

      #17
      Re: Dawson In As An Expo!!!!!!!

      I think it is a shame. Dawson even though he played only a few years there will always be a Cub in my mind and he won his MVP there so he should be allowed to go in there. This is not Boggs wanting to go in as a Ray for money. It is like Carter when he was forced to go in as a Expo when he will be remebered most for his Mets years by most fans and he won his championship there. The Hall defies logic sometimes.

      Comment

      • Buster
        Banned
        • Jan 2010
        • 40

        #18
        Re: Dawson In As An Expo!!!!!!!

        When a guy is elected into the hall, do you really think it matters?

        His career is reflective of his career. The whole career. It encompasses his playing time with every team. So everyone who ever liked the player should be happy no matter what "cap" he wears going in. Personally, I like the Expos pick. The cubs kinda always sucked since the goat thingie.

        Comment

        • legaleagle92481
          Banned
          • Oct 2009
          • 2538

          #19
          Re: Dawson In As An Expo!!!!!!!

          Originally posted by Buster
          When a guy is elected into the hall, do you really think it matters?

          His career is reflective of his career. The whole career. It encompasses his playing time with every team. So everyone who ever liked the player should be happy no matter what "cap" he wears going in. Personally, I like the Expos pick. The cubs kinda always sucked since the goat thingie.
          What is your favorite team? I am a Mets fan and when I go to Cooperstown I see the grand total of one plaque bearing my favorite team's cap. It is depressing because the Mets have not had the best players in their 48 year history and one of the few we have had is wearing some other team's cap. So I can see Cubs fans being Poed by the decision. After all who is their next hall of famer? One does not appear to be on the horizon and other than Sandberg their hall of famers played 30 plus years ago.

          Comment

          • Sincityson
            Senior Member
            • Oct 2006
            • 463

            #20
            Re: Dawson In As An Expo!!!!!!!

            Originally posted by legaleagle92481
            It is like Carter when he was forced to go in as a Expo when he will be remebered most for his Mets years by most fans and he won his championship there. The Hall defies logic sometimes.
            Carter as an Expo was a more obvious choice than Dawson as an Expo. Carter spent 11 seasons as an Expo, 5 with the Mets. Had good numbers with both, more All star appearances with the Expos, etc. Going in as a Met, would certainly been more financially beneficial for him.
            Following Game Used/Worn auctions and team sales: www.twitter.com/gameused

            Comment

            • dirtyla2000
              Senior Member
              • Apr 2008
              • 269

              #21
              Re: Dawson In As An Expo!!!!!!!

              Originally posted by sox83cubs84
              This "sour sports town" has 2 MLB teams...what does Montreal have left, baseball-wise? And, if Les Expos are such a big whoop-dee-doo, why have you turned on them now that they are in Washington? Sounds like the sour grapes are coming from someone other than me!

              Dave M.
              Chicago area
              Two teams, one championship! Monreal will have 3 hall of famers when all is said and done! LETS GO TIMMY RAINES,THE SECOND GREATEST LEADOFF MAN IN HISTORY!!!!!

              Comment

              • legaleagle92481
                Banned
                • Oct 2009
                • 2538

                #22
                Re: Dawson In As An Expo!!!!!!!

                Originally posted by dirtyla2000
                Two teams, one championship! Monreal will have 3 hall of famers when all is said and done! LETS GO TIMMY RAINES,THE SECOND GREATEST LEADOFF MAN IN HISTORY!!!!!
                Possibly four if Guerrero goes in as one under the Dawson standard. I.E. win your only MVP in one uniform go in to the Hall in another.

                Comment

                • sox83cubs84
                  Banned
                  • Apr 2009
                  • 8902

                  #23
                  Re: Dawson In As An Expo!!!!!!!

                  Originally posted by dirtyla2000
                  Two teams, one championship! Monreal will have 3 hall of famers when all is said and done! LETS GO TIMMY RAINES,THE SECOND GREATEST LEADOFF MAN IN HISTORY!!!!!

                  I won't argue with you on Raines...he's a favorite of mine, too.

                  Dave M.
                  Chicago area

                  Comment

                  • sox83cubs84
                    Banned
                    • Apr 2009
                    • 8902

                    #24
                    Re: Dawson In As An Expo!!!!!!!

                    Originally posted by dirtyla2000
                    Two teams, one championship! Monreal will have 3 hall of famers when all is said and done! LETS GO TIMMY RAINES,THE SECOND GREATEST LEADOFF MAN IN HISTORY!!!!!

                    BTW...2 teams, one championship beats 1 departed team and no championships.

                    Dave M.
                    Chicago area

                    Comment

                    • dirtyla2000
                      Senior Member
                      • Apr 2008
                      • 269

                      #25
                      Re: Dawson In As An Expo!!!!!!!

                      Originally posted by sox83cubs84
                      BTW...2 teams, one championship beats 1 departed team and no championships.

                      Dave M.
                      Chicago area
                      IN A 100 YEARS,NOT BY MUCH! CUBS ARE PERENIAL LOSERS BUT I DO LOVE THEM BLACKHAWKS,WHAT A TEAM,THEY MIGHT BRING CHICAGO THEIR ONLY CHAMPIONSHIP IN THE FORSEEABLE FUTURE!!

                      Comment

                      • sox83cubs84
                        Banned
                        • Apr 2009
                        • 8902

                        #26
                        Re: Dawson In As An Expo!!!!!!!

                        I do believe the Blackhawks will be the next Chicago team to win it all. Guess we agree on SOME things.

                        Dave M.
                        Chicago area

                        Comment

                        • legaleagle92481
                          Banned
                          • Oct 2009
                          • 2538

                          #27
                          Re: Dawson In As An Expo!!!!!!!

                          Originally posted by dirtyla2000
                          IN A 100 YEARS,NOT BY MUCH! CUBS ARE PERENIAL LOSERS BUT I DO LOVE THEM BLACKHAWKS,WHAT A TEAM,THEY MIGHT BRING CHICAGO THEIR ONLY CHAMPIONSHIP IN THE FORSEEABLE FUTURE!!
                          The Sox won in 1917 as well so that is two in 100 years. Which for a big City is just sad even my pathetic Mets and Knicks have two titles in the last 50 years.

                          Comment

                          Working...