Pete Rose possible reinstatement..

[tacprc]

Re: Pete Rose possible reinstatement..

Yeah, I have a problem with Selig making this decision.

He allowed the 1994 World Series to be canceled.

Note: That act may have doomed the Montreal Expos franchise.

He used his position to have the Milwaukee Brewers -- the team that he owns -- moved to the NL Central division.

He allowed baseballs to be juiced.

He allowed steroids to happen.

[cohibasmoker]

Re: Pete Rose possible reinstatement..

Joe Jackson and Pete Rose BOTH paid their dues and they should be allowed into the Hall of Fame.

If the Commissioner is worried about the integrity of the game, who's he kidding? Hey Commissioner, what about the guys who took steroids under your watch?

Jim

[sylbry]

Re: Pete Rose possible reinstatement..

To bring a good point back up that was said earlier:

It's the Hall of FAME, not Morality.

There are reasons why each member of the HOF is in there, it's because they were beyond good at what they did. Pete is the all time hit leader, so its obvious that he was beyond good at hitting right? So he should be in. He didnt cheat to get those hits. He didnt use PED's. He did it right. He just happened to do something on the side that was away from his moments at the plate.

Time heals all wounds.

If you think about it, that is what is happening here. The people who were outraged by Rose initially are losing interest and others who adamantly supported his ban are being replaced by a new generation who only see his performance, not his transgressions.

Makes me wonder how McGwire, Sosa, Clemens and the rest will be perceived in 20 years.

[coxfan]

Re: Pete Rose possible reinstatement..

I've no objection to putting Joe Jackson in the HOF and posthumously removing the ban on Buck Weaver, whose only offense was not revealing the others' plot. But I disagree that the "innocent" verdict exonerated anybody. The trial was a farce. Legal tecnicalities ( mainly ambiguities in the law) would have cleared them even if they'd all confessed! After the trial, the jury full of Sox fans celebrated at supper with the players.

Joe Jackson did confess, but his signed confession magically disappeared before the trial. Then it magically reappeared in the White Sox offices later when he sued them. Because of that, the lawsuit judge blocked his judgment on the grounds that he'd obviously perjured himself at one of the trials.

The real culprit who got away was Charles Comiskey, who almost certainly obtained and hid the confession in an effort to keep his players. There's no way he belongs in the HOF, but he's there.

[cincy13]

Re: Pete Rose possible reinstatement..

I knew I'd get blasted in here, but remember the NBA ref who made sure Tim Duncan fouled out to fix the playoffs? Come on, it could happen in baseball.

[tacprc]

Re: Pete Rose possible reinstatement..

My email address is tacprc@yahoo.com. Thanks. Chuck

[skyking26]

Re: Pete Rose possible reinstatement..

To bring a good point back up that was said earlier:

It's the Hall of FAME, not Morality.

There are reasons why each member of the HOF is in there, it's because they were beyond good at what they did. Pete is the all time hit leader, so its obvious that he was beyond good at hitting right? So he should be in. He didnt cheat to get those hits. He didnt use PED's. He did it right. He just happened to do something on the side that was away from his moments at the plate.

This is a solid point. You start going thru that Hall, you will find off the field adventures most likely aplenty. Rose for the Hall.

[NYCrulesU]

Re: Pete Rose possible reinstatement..

Forgiving people for their past mistakes is a beautiful thing.

I am a huge Pete Rose fan and collector.

I support Selig reinstating Rose -- at least for the purpose of allowing the current Baseball HOF members to vote on his HOF entry.

Chuck Lumb
Cincinnati native
Chicago resident

Chuck,

Do you have an email that I could contact you at?

[tacprc]

Re: Pete Rose possible reinstatement..

Forgiving people for their past mistakes is a beautiful thing.

I am a huge Pete Rose fan and collector.

I support Selig reinstating Rose -- at least for the purpose of allowing the current Baseball HOF members to vote on his HOF entry.

Chuck Lumb
Cincinnati native
Chicago resident

[brianborsch]

Re: Pete Rose possible reinstatement..

Joe Jackson was proven innocent in court. He should never have been banned. Besides that he is long dead. his sentence is up. Let him appear on the ballot already!

[joelsabi]

Re: Pete Rose possible reinstatement..

this is an interesting interview

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A7-SaS1AsRg&feature=related

[schubert1970]

Re: Pete Rose possible reinstatement..

I'm a huge Rose fan and when I initially heard the news today I was stunned.

As much as I think Pete was a great player, his gambling could have done more damage than good for the game of baseball. There are no excuses and he will never be in the HOF. If Pete was let in, what message will this send to the next player that thinks he's larger than the game itself. I think by keeping him out, it sends a srtong remider to the other players. If anything he will always serve the purpose as a stong example of what not to do.

For 90 years this rule has been posted in every clubhouse.

Rule 21
d) BETTING ON BALL GAMES. Any player, umpire, or club official or employee, who shall bet any sum whatsoever upon any baseball game in connection with which the bettor has no duty to perform shall be declared ineligible for one year.

Any player, umpire, or club or league official or employee, who shall bet any sum whatsoever upon any baseball game in connection with which the bettor has a duty to perform shall be declared permanently ineligible.

Seems simple to me.

[33bird]

Re: Pete Rose possible reinstatement..

No offense Cincy13 but you're way off base. I'm with Red October. Pete played to win every game and he managed the same way. The info is that he bet on the Red EVERY game-not just with certain pitchers. How much he bet I don't know. There's no way he manages and starts betting again baseball again. He'll probably always gamble but I'm sure he could give up betting baseball.

[murfsteve25]

Re: Pete Rose possible reinstatement..

To bring a good point back up that was said earlier:

It's the Hall of FAME, not Morality.

There are reasons why each member of the HOF is in there, it's because they were beyond good at what they did. Pete is the all time hit leader, so its obvious that he was beyond good at hitting right? So he should be in. He didnt cheat to get those hits. He didnt use PED's. He did it right. He just happened to do something on the side that was away from his moments at the plate.

[redoctober]

Re: Pete Rose possible reinstatement..

I'm a native cincinnatian, and a reds fan, but Pete should not be allowed back in baseball. People think since he bet on the reds to win, it's ok, the fact is, he bet on the reds to win if certain pitchers were in the lineup on that day; which means if the other pitchers were pitching he wouldn't bet, the bookies then knew what pete thought of the reds chances of winning on that day. The other reason is, the pros are never satisfied with what they make, if rose gets in, you will see players being bought to throw a game. Pete did bet on baseball when he was a player, some think it was only when he was a manager (according to an ex-player whos been aroung a loooong time). I loved watching Pete play, but greed rules; letting Pete in would only tell the current players that it's ok, you'll get in the HOF even if you throw a game. I'm just sayin.....

SERIOUSLY?????? You clearly have no idea about betting limits or sports betting in general. NO casino/bookie/sportsbook will take enough action on ONE game to make it worth "throwing" a game for a major league baseball player. PERIOD. The most you could get down is less than 5 figures -- please don't tell me that you believe that this is enough for a player to "throw a game"!!! Especially in baseball, where one player has much less impact than in a sport like say basketball.

Reinstating Rose would mean absolutely ZERO to current players, except that they may be able to benefit from his expertise if he was fully reinstated!!!

Compare Rose to the "steroid boys" and tell me who has affected the integrity of the game more. SERIOUSLY, is it even a debate????